End of Season report...

Would agree with most of that James, although i think you're being harsh on Vassell. I think he was pretty good when he was fit. Crowns tonight for the Manchester Derby?

Schmeichel 8
Peltier 6
Konchesky 8
Mills 5
Bamba 6
Gallagher 5
Howard 4
King 5
Dyer 6
St ledger 6
Vassell 6
Waghorn 5
Panayoitou n/a (unfair to mark someone on 15 mins)
Drinkwater 6
Johnson 3
Wellens 5
Beckford 7
Weale 3
Marshall 7
Danns 6
Morgan 6
Schlupp 6
Kennedy 5
Moore 5
Nugent 8

Sven 5
Pearson 4

Just one or two I’d take issue with there Sileby.

I think Shaun SL’s score is a bit high and for it to be the same as Konchesky is not representative in my opinion. PK has been consistent all season whereas SSL didn’t really improve until he got recalled to the team after his fallout with Pearson.

I also find your mark for Danns a bit generous. It might be fair for the second half of the season, but he was pretty poor for the first half even though there may have been extenuating factors.

I find myself much more aligned with Foxello’s scores and it feels quite nice to agree with him for a change.

PS Panayiotou gets the same score as Wellens for 15 minutes of fame?

I also agree with many of Foxello's scores:

Schmeichel 8
Peltier 6
Konchesky 8
Mills 5
Bamba 7
Gallagher 5
Howard 3
King 5
Dyer 6
St ledger 6
Vassell 5
Waghorn 5
Panayoitou n/a
Drinkwater 6
Johnson 3
Wellens 6
Beckford 6
Weale 5
Marshall 7
Danns 6
Morgan 7
Schlupp 6
Kennedy 6
Moore 6
Nugent 8

Sven 6
Pearson 6

We'd need mostly 7s and several 8s in order to mount a serious promotion challenge.

Dunge,

Has Chris Weale really had as big an impact on our season as Mills, Gallagher and King?

Perhaps 5 is overgenerous in comparison, you're right.