There have been quite a few over the past decade or so. Mine are.
Realms of the Haunting (PC) - Not many people know about this game but it was epic when it first came out. It was so scary I could only attempt to play it during the day. Never even clocked it.
SCARE RATING: 8/10
Silent Hill (PS1) - Man this was another scary game. That ringing bell and those little hobbit guys still send shivers down my spine.
SCARE RATING: 7.5/10
Alien vs Predator (PC) - Playing as a marine, this is by far the scariest game I've ever played. Those Aliens come out of no where and that sonar tracking system with its beeping sound does not help at all.
SCARE RATING:9.5/10
Scariest game you've played.
posted on 17/8/12
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 17/8/12
Project Zero/Fatal Frame was 12spooky144me.
I didn't even play it, just hid behind the sofa whilst a friend played through.
posted on 17/8/12
Resident evil 1 was jumpy!
Silent hill 1 & 2 were pretty freaky!
Resident evil 2 wasn't scary, but it was jumpy, same with Resident evil 3
posted on 17/8/12
Big Rigs: Over the Road Racing
You're winner!
_________________________________
That was one of the best things about that game. One of the only good things.
posted on 19/8/12
im too scared to play them, but fatal frame and silent hill 2 i tried to play
posted on 19/8/12
Dead Space 2 starts off scary, but the monsters become a bit too frequent and it get's tedious.
posted on 21/8/12
good god, get drunk and play 'slender' it's free to download from slendergame.com
that is pretty scary
posted on 25/8/12
FEAR
posted on 25/8/12
Good call. Creepy game but even better shooter. FEAR 2 had the scariest demo. Never played the full game.
posted on 28/8/12
Ah yes Big Rigs 2. The fantastic game where the opposing car waited patiently near the finish line while you crossed it. And of course you could reverse at infinite speed. Greatest game ever!