Nani > Valencia

Consistently puts crap crosses in and then does f all else? I'll take the other guy.

yea, supporting the team instead of bickering about which of your panto villains is worse is a sure sign of being a tool

Hmmm, one is mostly consistent but one dimensional, the other is inconsistent but on his day, world class. However his day comes a few times a season.

I'll go for the consistent guy
_______________________

The only thing consistent about Valencia's game is his kick and run into touch, his blind crosses and his fear of toching the ball with his left peg

Nani is hot and cold but even when hes cold, he can still counger up something out of nothing and when hes hot, he is unplayable

Consistently looses possession and shoots carelessly and doesn't engage his brain most of the time. I'll take the boring consistent guy most of the time.

We really do not need to choose though, we've got both of them

We really do not need to choose though, we've got both of them
___________________________________



Thats exactly why we need to choose

They can play together mate.

When we have Chicharito, Welbeck, RVP, Rooney, Kagawa, Young (plus Nani and Valencia) all vying for 4 spots, I doubt they will especially when both are best on the right

Defenders have sussed him! The trouble is, he doesn't know what to do with the ball if Raffa isn't making runs down his out-side. Why Scholes constantly crosses to him, i'll never know why!

Agree - (this season) Nani > Valencia ... and then some!!

Give it a rest . I not saying Valencia is world class but he way ahead of nani. Nani doesn't even try to play. Have saying it but hope he goes in January and we bring in a proper winger. Wonder who fergie rates higher

Overall I prefer Valencia but his form is poor right now and Nani should be given a few games to prove himself. All our wingers have been disappointing this season so far.