What is our best XI?

................. Dea Gea

Raffa ... Smalling ... Evans ... Evra

...........Carrick. ...Anderson..

Nani........Rooney ....... Kagawa

..................Van Persie

On form then Vidic in for Evans. But i feel too many injuries may have taken there toll!

................. Dea Gea

Raffa ... Smalling ... Evans ... Evra

...........Carrick. ...Anderson..

Nani........Rooney ....... Kagawa

..................Van Persie

Id possibly swop Vidic for Evans if fit but otherwise this looks the strongest i can think of.

Yes that is, I wish we would play it sometime.

I agree with the OPs Team almost entirely. It's only the CBs, but I don't disagree, I'm just undecided ATM on who the best partnership is.
Gun to my head I'd probably agree, but I don't think there's a clear best at the moment

I think it massively depends on the type of game.

But overall i would go with:

--------------------De Gea-----------------------

Rafael------Vidic?-----Evans---------Evra

--------------Carrick------Anderson----------

Nani----------------Rooney----------Kagawa

--------------------Van Persie

Subs: Lindegaard, Ferdinand, Smalling, Cleverley, Valencia, Scholes, Hernandez/Welbeck

I'd go with your team:

---------------De Gea-------------------
Rafeal---Vidic---Smalling---Evra
------------Cleverly---Anderson-----
Nani-----------Rooney--------Kagawa
-----------------RVP-----------------------

I'd really love to see tht team out on the field in a big game

None of this matters anyway as that side will not be picked by Fergie unless Carrick, Scholes and Giggs are all out injured and even then he'd probably put Jones into CM ahead of Anderson and Tom.

De Gea

Rafael
Vidic/Smalling
Evans
Evra

Cleverly/Carrick
Anderson

Nani
Rooney
Kagawa

RVP

De Gea
Rafael Smalling Evans Evra
Anderson Cleverley
Nani Rooney Kagawa
Van Persie

I see a trend appearing here. In

Everyone agrees with

De Gea

Rafael

Evra

Anderson

Rooney
Kagawa

RVP

Then it is simply a case of 2 of Evans, Smalling and Vidic

One of Carrick and Cleverly and either Nani or Valenica...

Has a fanbase ever been in such agreement against the line ups we have been seeing?