In for Willian

But the answer to that problem isn't to sign a Winger/AMC. I do agree that a CM is a priority, but that doesn't mean just anybody should be signed.

Maybe others just want a signing of any kind

The occasions I have seen him play, I was very impressed... top quality.

We didn't "need" RVP, but it sure did help.

In that case, it's whether you think Willian would be considerably better than the current options, and I don't from what I've seen.

In other news, the reliable Cadena Ser are reporting:

@barcastuff: Despite a report in the English press, Barcelona have no indications that Man United are preparing another bid for Cesc Fabregas. [ser]

Shameful journalism from The Telegraph

Willian is a good player, he is better than young, valencia and cleverley, improvement.

After a CM a LW is our priority IMO. Other than Giggs we actually have no left footed left wingers, ideally Kagawa will be played centrally and for me Januzaj isn't ready. That only leaves us with Nani who I want on the right and Young. Willian is a far better option on the left wing than anyone we currently have.

Willian won't be going to Liverpool, he's letting the top 4-5 clubs in the league that he's available and would like a move to the Premier League, he's good enough for a Champions League club or at least a club who will be likely to be in the competition next season.

We need a left winger.

Yes, we have 4 wingers in Nani, Young, Valencia and Zaha. Yes, 3 of those can play on the left. But Zaha isn't ready, Young has his injury problems and in my mind should be sold and Nani is better on the right competing with Valencia.

Sell Young, bring in William, problem of too many players sorted. I do think Young would do better at a club like Tottenham or lower than anyone in the top 3.

Lmao.... oh, this is a real discussion?

The only reason I can think of that young hasn't been sold and replaced by a much better player is that no club has made a bd purely because there not prepared to match the astronomical wages he is on at the club.