or to join or start a new Discussion

11 Comments
Article Rating 4.5 Stars

Yesterdays goal

Those blaming Preece for yesterday's goal need to look at the video again, the only time the ball is anywhere near him is when our defender (I think it's Edwards) clears in front of him, and it's clearly the centre half's ball.
Chaplow should not even have been booked he cleared the ball and it was just a collision.
Butterfield was dominated by Jack Cork who knocked him off the ball and dispossessed him on several occasions and the passes he did manage were inaccurate, however KH should not have played him at the side of Addison but swopped with Doyle who I suppose was further forward to stop Saints building from the back; it didn't work.
Several players looked nervous, surprising after Forest, and we were never able to move the ball forward so Haynes and Davies were starved of good supply but you have to credit Saints for they're tactics.
Booing just doesn't help, perhaps when those people stop coming we can create a better atmosphere and get behind the team, who clearly need some help.
It's early days yet so there is no need for doom and gloom just look at the last 5 seasons, again I believe there will be at least 3 teams worse than us.
Addison and Perkins, and Vaz Te perhaps our best performers.

posted on 14/8/11

That may well be, but isn't that sad in itself, and indicative of our me me society. People used to be supportive of their teams, their families and friends and their workmates. Thatcher's generation, and we're the poorer for it!

comment by kinnell (U2619)

posted on 14/8/11

Preece was initially at fault in the build up to the goal,
he should have shouted keepers ball and caught the first header across his goal, he showed no domination of his 6 yard box, having said that the header away by McNulty was a powder puff effort, should have dealt with it better, this player is no central defender IMO,
Sloppy defending by a Div 2 standard defender...

comment by madrush (U5998)

posted on 14/8/11

Agree with a few points here; I feel Preece should have commanded his area and come for the initial ball, but once the defenders took over they had two or three chances to clear. It was like the Keystone Cops.

Addison was ineffective, and I question why we played with him as 'sweeper', effectively in a back 5, at home. Doyle is also a defensive midfielder, so essentially it was a very negative set-up.

Perkins showed glimpses of promise but without any end product. McNulty was out of his depth and McEverley was simply hopeless.

Chapelow had to go; it was right in front of us in the East Stand and he clearly stamped. Stupid.

As for the booing, that's just idiotic; yes, it was truly awful, but booing in the first home league game? With any luck those brainless neanderthals won't come back.

Big improvement on TUesday please Mr Hill...

posted on 14/8/11

From watching it, I think Preece probably could have called for it and claimed it and also the near post where the header went in should have been covered better from both McNulty and Preece.

However, S'hampton had plenty of chances and should really have been 2 or 3 up. I think Preece made enough good saves to redeem himself. My only real grumble with him is that it seem to take him ages to distrubute the ball from goal.

Also Perkins really put a shift in yesterday, I was pleased with his work rate, but if he is to play in this division there are so many aspects of his game he needs to work on.

comment by (U7380)

posted on 14/8/11

The only reason Preece never got near the ball is because he didn't move his feet. Nor does he command the area or communicate with defenders. On yesterdays showing if Hill continues with one up front especially at home it needs two wide men, Vaz-Te may be a showman but he has flair and will run at defenders, apart from Davies he was the only player who took the game to the opposition. Southampton are a class team and will be promoted but as Hill said after the game the two full backs had nothing to occupy them and became attackers down the flanks.

posted on 14/8/11

Vaz te & Hassell would both start on Tuesday, for me

posted on 15/8/11

The goal was down to shocking defending, right from the keeper to all four defenders. Preece had more than one chance to claim the ball but didnt. The defenders head tennis was diabolical and no better than league 2 football from league 2 players.

We played with 2 ineffectual central defensive midfielders. Addison looked slow and laboured and only had one moment of inspiration where he surged forward. Doyle has never been able to pass.!! As someone has already said this resulted in no service to the front player(s). Our most threatening/dangerous looking player, Haynes, starts out wide.?????

The sending off was correct, watching the replay over you can see Chaplow deliberately throws his foot in to McEveley.

Poor attendance for the first home game of the season. Down 3 thousand on 2 years ago... Are people waiting to see how we perform before spending money. I came to see if there had been an improvement though was concerned by the signings we'd made. looks like my fears were justified...

posted on 15/8/11

We're 2 games in. Give them a chance

comment by Maximus (U9642)

posted on 15/8/11

How many times have I heard ....''its only a couple of games in''...''give them a chance'' ......I can't remember the last time any of us said 'Great second result.... 6 points.....bring it on etc etc. I'm not saying its wrong to be cautious or pessamistic but it would be nice just to start a season once in a while with a bit of cheer instead of staring down the barrel of a gun ...more so this season with the quality of teams whats in this league. I genuinely think we will be tanked by cricket scores in some away games... but its the teams around us that we must put away clinically..... home and away. Some nutter I can't remember who, did a predictions list earlier in the close season and suggested most games would be losses. Come on lads wake up and smell the coffee. We can do a lot better than the relegation armchair monkeys, fairweather supporters and Cup Run ticket thieves will have us believe.

comment by kinnell (U2619)

posted on 15/8/11

And where do you class yourself amongst those groups of supporters, Maximus.
Youve been on this forum 2 minutes, with nowt but negative vibes, now your slagging the precious fans of Barnsley, under your assumed Roman type emporor name (Spartacus copycat), you ought to be named Prophet of Doom.
Put a few words of truth in your personal profile, so we know what kind of fan you are.
Times are hard for people in the town at the moment, but the club needs every one of them to support the club through good and bad times.
Reduced attendance's will mean less cash available to invest in better players, as we are discovering at the moment, we have to live within our means.
Yes the last 2 games have been poor, but give the team a chance to turn it around, those games are gone, bring on the Boro.
We have a new managerial set up and some players that are new to the demands of championship football, let them find their feet before you judge them, how would you feel if some of them turned out to be prized assets come the transfer window.
I bet you splashed about a bit when you were thrown in the deep end.

C'Mon You Redddzz

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 4.5 from 2 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available