Player Ratings

comment by Sto17neS (one of the decent posters) (U18934)
posted 2 minutes ago
happened in a split second edin. the ball from the young kid was perfect and chiriches went the wrong way. he had not time to go out. got a hand to it and was a bit unlucky, but other than having a bit of luck for it, couldnt have done any more in my view. made a number of fantastic saves.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I dont think he needed to go out. Welbeck had such a tight angle that a wonder hit would have been needed to beat Lloris.

Instead he had an easy chip.

lloris is a madman. his decision making is woeful at least once a game and it will cost us.

on the other hand, he often makes very good saves or clearances so i guess you have to take the good with the bad.

does my heart no good at all though

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

IMO he's turning into another Gomes does brilliant but then has a few moments of madness

He was good yes, just not 10/10 good I feel.

Kentaleb

Walker fan club - Me, Edin, Analog

=======

Ahhh bless...



Sod all this player rating lark...what about knocking the statue of AVB down and replacing it with Timmy Sherwood...after all, beating Man Utd at OT is legendry status no questions asked - isn't it?

comment by Sto17neS (one of the decent posters) (U18934)
posted 2 hours, 48 minutes ago
I misread your previous comment edin.

will have a look at it again on MOTD.

regardless, his performance was superb imo.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Having seen MOTD now? Thoughts?

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

I meant that he could do better, which I still believe he could.

Rose a 5 for me, thought he was poor.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

What a dreadful start to the NY I am ageeing with edinspur .........................