Herrera

RR, yes and this is where I'm questioning the manager's judgement.

Andy Carroll is terrible, under no circumstances should he ever be at Old Trafford - unless he's playing for the away team.

comment by RedReason (U5677)
posted 1 minute ago
Face it fellas our biggest loss has been other clubs not being scared of us, and this was becoming the case under SAF too


----------------------------------------------------------------------

True. That and 4 teams all of who are taking advantage of every point dropped.

VC and DArren

TBH fellas I wasn't against the fellaini signing initially

I actually saw qualities in him that even carrick lacked and I really rate carrick. For example I don't think carrick presses forward as much and as quick

In fact the only doubt I had was him playing next to carrick, I thought he would be in place of carrick

Well than that was your mistake for assuming Carrick would be dropped.

For example I don't think carrick presses forward as much and as quick

....................

My gran can press quicker than Fellaini.

And she has been dead for five years.

Fellaini just isn't a midfield player, under any stretch of imagination.

VC

I guess time will tell and if Carricks Achilles is as bad as some say then Fellaini in his position maywell turn out to be a bit of a coup

then Fellaini in his position maywell turn out to be a bit of a coup

...............

I haven't seen one performance from him that will suggest this.

He is slow, he can't tackle, he can't read the game and he can't pass like Carrick.

And he hasn't been dominant in the air either.

VC - I actually agree with that to a degree

My point is that just because he hasn't at UTD doesn't necessarily mean he cant. lets take the air example

I didn't watch everton regularly but when I did he was, for example, fantastic in the air. I also think some of his ariel challenges were not given as freekicks unlike since he came to UTD

For some reason he hasn't been dominant in the air at UTD however is this due to being awe stricken or injury? I dont know.

Whatever the reason its fact that he hasn't been dominant in the air

what is also fact is that he was and is for Blegium

what he didn't appreciate I suspect was the tempo and manner in which United teams are expected to play

.............

You would have thought he would understand this having played against us twenty plus times.
........................................................................
well in signing Fellaini as a solution, he must be inept or just plain stupid...............................