Dundee U v St J - it was not to be...

What has Jackie actually done that makes him a better manager?
Took a team that most people thought could get second and finished third? Won hee haw?

lauders

some seem to want him as the next celtic manager, don't get it tbh.

I think Jackie gets overrated because United have some players that a lot of people like.

Lauders, the point of the thread wasnt about the merits or otherwise of JM but simply that the better team on the day won the game.

untied have some good young players, they remind me of hibs when they had brown, Thompson, fletcher etc.

that hibs team was better though.

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

comment by curly - The future is kilbirnie ladeside; less phannys than the rangers board and mair baws than king (U1103)
posted 1 hour, 16 minutes ago
Watching Utd yesterday was like watching Rangers in the Ramsdens final, no shape or structure and very little effort
----------------------------------------------------------------------
offfft !! Now thats insulting

I meant fourth obviously.

And I was replying to your point (in the op) that Jackie is a better manager.
I was asking how you came to this conclusion?

Lauders, I don't know who is the better manager between Wright and JM and if my post suggested that JM was the better manager then that wasn't the intent.
You don't rate him which is your prerogative.
Again my point was that Saints won because they were better on the day.

" Wright is probably not a bettermanager than JM"