1) Aguero
2) Ramsey
3) Fabregas
4) Sanchez
5) Yaya
posted on 3/9/14
comment by The Chavy One (U12176)
posted 1 minute ago
HUNTING FOR GLORY
Always thought Cesc and RVP were quality players at Arsenal, I reckon Cesc has become a better player at Barcelona just because he has had players like Xavi, Iniesta and Messi to learn a trick or two from.
RVP was a beast at Arsenal I thought hence why United went all out to get him and why he more or less won them the league.
Ramsey has the potential to be world class but to suggest he is now is premature to say the least
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree with most of the things you said apart from Cesc getting better cos of the players at Barca statement
Most players get better with experience, and Cesc is no different, dont forget he already used to train & play with Xavi & Iniesta for the national team
Its all about opinions anyway and in my opinion he would have also have improved had he stayed at Arsenal, and imo would be a 1st team starter for the national team. Just like i assume he'll be now that he's at Chelsea.
I also find it strange that you're ok with others including players like Di Maria, Falcao etc in their top 5 list even though they havent proved themselves in the Prem, but you decide to single out Ramsey.
A Chelsea fan more than most should know that buying a world class big name player doesn't necessarily guarantee that they'll be a success in the Prem.
posted on 3/9/14
Huntingforglory i put Dimaria because of how good he was for Real i didn't judge Ozil on Real because he's had one year at Arsenal Dimaria has played one game
posted on 3/9/14
I'm not singling out Ramsey, This is a football discussion forum and I'm disagreeing with the OP that Ramsey isn't IMO one of the top 5 players in the league, He's a very good player no doubt but world class? Not for me.
posted on 3/9/14
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 3/9/14
comment by United we win (U19958)
posted 23 seconds ago
now Falcao and Di Maria has joined Utd they are averagethey are better than anything at Arsenal, City and Chelsea and would walk into those sides. Arsenal's best striker is Welbeck ffs
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Who said they were average?
Just dont think its fair or accurate to include them in the Top 5 players in the prem, without either of them actually proving it in the prem.
Its like including Rojo in the list of best defenders in the prem!!!
It would be absurd
posted on 3/9/14
comment by KrisBhoy (U18817)
posted 19 minutes ago
Huntingforglory i put Dimaria because of how good he was for Real i didn't judge Ozil on Real because he's had one year at Arsenal Dimaria has played one game
----------------------------------------------------------------------
But this is list of prems top 5, not La Liga's top 5
Common sense would say Di Maria has to prove he can do it in the Prem before you can put him in a list of Top 5, No?
What so difficult to grasp about that?
At the moment the only Top 5 list Di Maria, Falcao, Sanchez etc can be included, is potential best signings
posted on 3/9/14
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 3/9/14
comment by United we win (U19958)
posted 29 seconds ago
HUNTING FOR GLORY (U16317)
No it's not, what a crazy example. So if Messi joined the league he would not make it in the top 5and you include Rojo as an example to back up your dumb statement? rojo about 12 months ago was probably known by no one and has huge question marks over his ability. Falcao and Di Maria for about the last 4 seasons have proved they are world class and cut above the rest and that includes everyone in this league.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What a ridiculous come back. Especially when you consider Utd fans favorite argument when comparing Messi & Ronaldo is that Messi hasnt done it in the prem
If Messi came to the prem, he would still be the best player in the world, but until he proves it in the prem , you cant put him in the Prem's Top 5.
Shevchenko was a world class player, but couldnt cut it in the prem, Likewise Veron.
Until a player actually proves he's worth, its ridiculous to include them in Top 5 player list.
Whats so difficult to comprehend about that
posted on 3/9/14
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 3/9/14
comment by United we win (U19958)
posted 32 seconds ago
HUNTING FOR GLORY (U16317)
If you are using that as your methodology. Then surly RVP and Mata make that side, after all, they have been the best creators and scorers over the past few years.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
RVP definitely makes the list.
But they have been more efficient midfielders/play makers/No.10's in the prem than Mata, eg Silva, Toure, so unfortunately he doesn't make the cut