Who got the best deal?

phil neville


No i don't think I am a hypocrite. Loads of people have been slagging off Markovic who only cost £20m. No one is mentioning a player who has been pulled off at half time for being so poor and he cost £34m. Big difference there

Re Herrera, I saw an article last week where people were calling him a better signing than Welbeck so far. Got to laugh.

comment by T Bone Steak Roysters (U3947)
posted 8 minutes ago
phil neville


No i don't think I am a hypocrite. Loads of people have been slagging off Markovic who only cost £20m. No one is mentioning a player who has been pulled off at half time for being so poor and he cost £34m. Big difference there
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Both are new to the Premiership and Herrera has the added pressure of playing for a massive club

Herrera has been fantastic for us - probably because we as United fans aren't used to seeing a decent CM... Bear in mind what we've had to put up with over the last 6 years or so and you'll understand some United fans going over the top.

They've been about as impactful as each other really with Welbeck actually doing what most of us knew he could - and sticking the ball in the net and creating chances.

Who did United sign for £34m ?

comment by T Bone Steak Roysters (U3947)




posted 15 minutes ago



phil neville


No i don't think I am a hypocrite. Loads of people have been slagging off Markovic who only cost £20m. No one is mentioning a player who has been pulled off at half time for being so poor and he cost £34m. Big difference there


==

To be fair on Falcao and Markovic I can only base my judgement on them on the games they have played against Everton.

Falcao scored a crucial goal..........

Markovic failed to really test the Everton back line. Neither have set the PL on fire, one will probably go back after teh loan....the other will stay for another try or be loaned out to Sunderland and then told he wont get any playing time

comment by Arouna Jagielka oooh I wanna take ya, Heitinga Nikica come on pretty mama (U1308)
posted 44 minutes ago
comment by T Bone Steak Roysters (U3947)




posted 15 minutes ago



phil neville


No i don't think I am a hypocrite. Loads of people have been slagging off Markovic who only cost £20m. No one is mentioning a player who has been pulled off at half time for being so poor and he cost £34m. Big difference there


==

To be fair on Falcao and Markovic I can only base my judgement on them on the games they have played against Everton.

Falcao scored a crucial goal..........

Markovic failed to really test the Everton back line. Neither have set the PL on fire, one will probably go back after teh loan....the other will stay for another try or be loaned out to Sunderland and then told he wont get any playing time
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Bringing up Borini again huh? You really do love him

I think if you guys put your club bias to one side (difficult I know) it has to be Eto'o so far and by some way, he's already scored 4 goals and 3 of them have been crucial! Drogba may do well this season but it only started on Sunday.....

comment by The God Fowler - Henderson for Captain (U2538)



posted 32 minutes ago


comment by Arouna Jagielka oooh I wanna take ya, Heitinga Nikica come on pretty mama (U1308)
posted 44 minutes ago
comment by T Bone Steak Roysters (U3947)




posted 15 minutes ago



phil neville


No i don't think I am a hypocrite. Loads of people have been slagging off Markovic who only cost £20m. No one is mentioning a player who has been pulled off at half time for being so poor and he cost £34m. Big difference there


==

To be fair on Falcao and Markovic I can only base my judgement on them on the games they have played against Everton.

Falcao scored a crucial goal..........

Markovic failed to really test the Everton back line. Neither have set the PL on fire, one will probably go back after teh loan....the other will stay for another try or be loaned out to Sunderland and then told he wont get any playing time
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Bringing up Borini again huh? You really do love him


==

You mentioned Borini

Eto'o looks to have been a cracking signing.

Here is my fav reply to the same question on NOT606

===

Originally Posted by Gerrez

I've no idea what you're talking about, I don't use JA606. I have an account but only because I signed up there (along with here and SW) when the original 606 closed.

Listing our two clubs strikers in order of (my) preference:
1.Sturridge
2.Lukaku
3.Eto'o
4.Koné
5.Lambert
6.Naismith
7.Borini
8.Balotelli

So you guys have the better crop of forwards but we have the best one (ignoring injury records of course :P)