Feedback Thread

While I think that already this is the best alternative to 606 so far, here are some things that could be improved. Some of them are quite small, and you could call it nitpicking, but just my view:

Smileys...
I know it's been said many times but this needs some. If the BBC Smilies are not available and you have to create some ideally could there be the vareity that BBC had and also please no animated ones - IMO makes the site look tacky

Zoom out?
Possible for the page to either align on the left our zoom out so it covers the whole page? Just generally looks strange on desktop and it's a pain to zoom out every time you're on the iPhone when on normal 606 the zoom it was on was fine.

Remember Me
When logging there is no 'remember me' option, meaning I'll have to go throughthe whole typing in e-mail and password before accessng anything.

Latest Activity on Member Page
Very confusing, needs to be more like the original. If you comment twice on an article it actually shows the two comments individually unnescarily clogging up the member page. When someone replies, instead of showing 'latest reply' it says 'posted' which is what it says when you originally post something...meaning that you don't know whether this is your comment or someone else's reply.

Time-Limit Comments
While I'm glad that the whole 3 minute rule is gone, I think this still needs a time-limit between comments - at least 30 seconds and at themost 1 and a haldf minutes. Need to keep the site as WUM Free as possible - it's a clean slate after all!

Search
I know it was the same on 606 but the search is pretty useless. Is it possible that when you use search it actually searches both the title of the article, any tags, and the content of both the articles and comments?

Event Articles, Match articles etc.
Think they should come back on create an article. Quite useful when making a report on a match or if you want to include a number of teams.

Member count
Place where we can see amount of members?

Home Page for Website
While I like the blog, could we also see something like http://sportwitness.ning.com/ and http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/606/default.stm where we can see the latest news and/or best articles? Just think it looks more profressional and interesting.

Links
You'll probably find that the links don't work for some reason so even though it's copied and pasted it right you can't click on it straight away and have to go through the tedious process of copying and pasting yoursself

Character limit on articles?
Is there any? Instead of 5000 it says NaN at the bottom of create an article page.

? ?
No bold and italics Very useful tool on 606, among other things like the qoute box and table etc. Could easily be implemented couldn't it? And although the original didn't have it, could we also have it on comments, at least just bold and italics?

Cheers

Thoughts and mine, and what your feedback is on the website?