or to join or start a new Discussion

23 Comments
Article Rating 1 Star

Ibe vs Reine-Adelaide

I don't know much about these two players, apart from the fact that they're both highly-rated talents.

Does anyone have any good insight into their abilities? Who's the bigger talent?

Predictions on how their careers will pan out? The next Aliadiere & Mellor or the next Anelka & Fowler?

Just a light-hearted comparison.

comment by Szoboss (U6997)

posted on 28/7/15

I'm lead to believe that Ibe was originally thought to be the more likely of him and Sterling to make it. I can't help but think that much of that came from concerns over Sterling's physical presence when compared to Ibe very obvious physical attributes.

Sterling is much the better player at them moment. Shouldn't even be a discussion.

That's not to say Ibe doesn't have talent though, he clearly has it in abundance. What struck me immediately about Sterling was his positional awareness, he seemed to understand what he was supposed to do and where he was supposed to be in relation to other players on the pitch. It's incredibly rare for such a young player IMO and it's allowed him to make an impact at that young age.

It's unlikely Ibe will have an 'explode onto the scene' season in the way Sterling did a couple back. Not impossible but unlikely. One thing I do know for sure however is that I'm excited about what he can bring to the team.

posted on 28/7/15

Firm in hoe
Spot on, well put.

posted on 28/7/15

I don't think Sterling and Ibe are similar at all, other than both being attacking players.

Sterling is tactically very good, he tracks back well, tackles and intercepts well for a small guy, and is deceptively strong. His off the ball movement is very good, and he is very very quick with and without the ball. He is not very good technically in terms of ball striking, that's the only thing really missing from his game of the main attributes you would want. His left foot is just for standing on. He plays with his head up well and can spot a pass but the execution can let him down.

Ibe on the other hand strikes a ball fantastically, with real power on either side..He is a very powerful runner and has more tricks than Sterling on the ball. His off the ball work is not as good though, both attacking and defending, and too often he plays with his head down, looking to dribble passed everyone when teammates are better placed.

I think Sterling will ultimately be the more effective player, but Ibe will more be exciting to watch and will do things that Sterling can't. I expect Sterling to be more consistent over time, but Ibe can be a very good player. How good Ibe becomes will be determined by his goals tally, as I don't see him being a serial assister. I think Sterling can be more productive for others while not necessarily being prolific himself.

Never seen this Arsenal kid so can't comment on him.

posted on 28/7/15

If rodgers lets Ibe play his game instead of trying to turn him into a wingback, he has the potential to go as far as he wants.
Rodgers got too obsessed with players being able to "fill in" rather than play them where they are best....markovic has been the same as he isnt a wing back.

posted on 28/7/15

Ibe will become the better player. I think if he stays injury free and gets a run he will develop into a key player for us. Lets judge him after 100 games. His stats will be far superior to Sterlings imo

posted on 28/7/15

So many new posters are absolute cringeworthy mugs. And this board is surpassing even its usual level of shi.ttiness today.

posted on 28/7/15

What a self righteous

posted on 28/7/15

If Ibe plays his cards right he could be the next Zaha!

posted on 28/7/15

For what it's worth, I got the same feeling watching R-L's first game in an Arsenal shirt to the first time I laid eyes on TH14 at the world cup.

posted on 29/7/15

Ibe is a great outfield player with quick feet, huge potential but gets himself stuck in deadends a lot. Once he learns when best to pass he'll be fantastic.

Reins is a goalkeeper. He hasn't played for us in a long time.

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 1 from 1 vote

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available