Well I Suppose This Will Please Some of You

Why do Rockstar need to redeem themselves. Everything they make is great.

It's just a joke - I seem to be the only person on Earth who didn't like the original RDR.

You heathen Hobo, how can you not like that game (to be fair it took me ages to get into it and I still hate the first half hour or so of it but top class story and game in the end)

I enjoyed RDR, but, is it as good as GTA V? or even as memorable as GTA Vice City?

No is my answer

Definitely still buy it though, but not on release

I thought red dead was boring....
The zombie game was a bit of crack though

Excellent game with a great ending. I actually really liked playing through the online missions as well with friends.

I wasn't really so bothered about the rest of the online games although it did have some interesting versions of it. The shootouts at the beginning was a really interesting idea for example.

Looking forward to it and as a PC gamer for the most part these days it might even make me buy a new console.