how bad have referee decisions been compared to last season. To me they seem to be getting worse and worse as each season goes by. Is it time to introduce rugby style refereeing, hold the play, ask fourth official to view the result and then make the decision.
Discuss
referee decisions
posted on 23/1/17
I think we need to move to a more open minded approach to interpretation. Football is moving away from being a contact sport and I think our interpretation needs to reflect this. It is not as clear cut as “was their physical contact”, or not? We need to assess each incident on an emotional and psychological basis, with a focus on gender equality. If a player goes down like a big girl it’s important for us to consider their lifestyle and take steps to be more accepting of it. Give an equal amount of decisions to players acting like big girls. Who are we to say that being a big girl is not correct? Big girls are beautiful too. But skinny models?? YUCK! You are disgusting. The way you look is incorrect. It’s important not to be nasty to someone due to their appearance. I think introducing sticks of celery instead of half time pies would also do the world of good.
posted on 23/1/17
Referees are no better or worse than in the past. It's just that their mistakes are more highlighted and scrutinised than ever. They are prone to human error and sometimes pure incompetence. Some limited use of video technology would help but there is great opposition to its introduction. The right to have endless discussions and arguments amongst fans seems to be preferable to using any video technology as this is seen to dilute the purity of the beautiful game.
posted on 23/1/17
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 23/1/17
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 23/1/17
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 23/1/17
I agree brightdave.
The players are the main culprits, the cheating on even whose throw-in it is as almost automatic. The diving, contesting nearly every decision, the headshaking if they get a yellow for even the most blatant full. We get the referees we deserve.
posted on 23/1/17
foul*
posted on 23/1/17
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 23/1/17
comment by Marcus Haber (U1734)
posted 1 hour, 10 minutes ago
I think we need to move to a more open minded approach to interpretation. Football is moving away from being a contact sport and I think our interpretation needs to reflect this. It is not as clear cut as “was their physical contact”, or not? We need to assess each incident on an emotional and psychological basis, with a focus on gender equality. If a player goes down like a big girl it’s important for us to consider their lifestyle and take steps to be more accepting of it. Give an equal amount of decisions to players acting like big girls. Who are we to say that being a big girl is not correct? Big girls are beautiful too. But skinny models?? YUCK! You are disgusting. The way you look is incorrect. It’s important not to be nasty to someone due to their appearance. I think introducing sticks of celery instead of half time pies would also do the world of good.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Think you are definately on to something there
posted on 23/1/17
Make the 4th official do something constructive other than just standing there criticizing a manager for over celebrating.