Kane To Madrid Swap Deal ?

comment by Sheriff John Brown - bring back David Dein (U7482)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by HRH King Ledley (U20095)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Sheriff John Brown - bring back David Dein (U7482)
posted 10 minutes ago
comment by HRH King Ledley (U20095)
posted 6 minutes ago
Even if wages were no concern, it would be no from me.

If Bale was always fit it would be a different story, but he rarely is. Modric at 32, Benzema at 30 and a Bale you can barely play for half the fixtures.

Not a hope in hell.


----------------------------------------------------------------------

If Bale was always fit, no one would swap him for Kane in the first place.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

I do not think it would be cut and dried.

I think most PL clubs would pick Kane if offered the two right now, and Bale was fit. Guaranteed upwards of 20 league goals a season, and just 24.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

If Bale was fit, he could be banging in over 20 a season quite simply. He doesn't play the same role, which means it would make no sense to be comparing his scoring record with Kane. He actually has other things to offer. Frightening pace to terrify defences, a wicked cross and shot on him, and the unique ability to score from nothing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I am not comparing their scoring record, just stating Kane will guarantee upwards of 20 PL goals a season as pretty much the best all-round centre forward in the division - all types of goal, all distances, both feet and head.

Upwards of 20 is being pretty modest too. His record is now 2-in-3, and since the start if last season it is 35 goals in 37 PL games.

He also has 4 years on Bale. With his non-reliance on explosive pace, he could be a club's main striker for the next decade

comment by The RC is back (U21185)
posted 14 minutes ago

----------------------------------------------------------------------
RC

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Sheriff John Brown - bring back David Dein (U7482)
posted 2 hours, 14 minutes ago
comment by HRH King Ledley (U20095)
posted 6 minutes ago
Even if wages were no concern, it would be no from me.

If Bale was always fit it would be a different story, but he rarely is. Modric at 32, Benzema at 30 and a Bale you can barely play for half the fixtures.

Not a hope in hell.


----------------------------------------------------------------------

If Bale was always fit, no one would swap him for Kane in the first place.
Y
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr know-it-all has spoken 🙄
Tells em like he’s some kind of authority 🙄

We might be better for it, we might not. More depth but I wouldn't underestimate the loss of Kane. Benzema is not nearly as good as a replacement.

We might be better for it, we might not. More depth but I wouldn't underestimate the loss of Kane. Benzema is not nearly as good as a replacement.
---------------------------------------------

Benzema's general ability and link-up play is different class from Kane. Football isn't all about goals, even for strikers. And Benzema's own record is underrated too. It's a tad ridiculous to say he's "not nearly as good" as Kane.

comment by Sheriff John Brown - bring back David Dein (U7482)
posted 8 minutes ago
We might be better for it, we might not. More depth but I wouldn't underestimate the loss of Kane. Benzema is not nearly as good as a replacement.
---------------------------------------------

Benzema's general ability and link-up play is different class from Kane. Football isn't all about goals, even for strikers. And Benzema's own record is underrated too. It's a tad ridiculous to say he's "not nearly as good" as Kane.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Kane is quality outside of scoring himself.

Maybe I've undersold Benzema as he is a very good player, but I believe Kane to be better and I think he's more driven, hence him continuing to improve even now.

comment by Sheriff John Brown - bring back David Dein (U7482)
posted 14 minutes ago
We might be better for it, we might not. More depth but I wouldn't underestimate the loss of Kane. Benzema is not nearly as good as a replacement.
---------------------------------------------

Benzema's general ability and link-up play is different class from Kane. Football isn't all about goals, even for strikers. And Benzema's own record is underrated too. It's a tad ridiculous to say he's "not nearly as good" as Kane.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Having good link up play is all well and good, but Benzema consistently does that with Ronaldo, Bale etc top wingers.

Don't think it's fair to say either way how he would do in the PL with Spurs, but my gut instinct is I'd rather have Kane, especially considering Kane is, what, six years younger than Benzema.

Who writes this rubbish

Throw in Asensio, Kovacic and Isco as well and they’ve got a deal but until then no