It was brought up on another thread but I think it's worth a thread of its own.
Here are McInnes' transfers in over the last two seasons and my opinion on if they were a success or a failure:
Stockley - Failure
Lewis - Success
Alexander - Back up
Morris - Failure
O'Connor - Failure
Storey - Failure
Burns (loan) - Failure
Maddison (loan) - Success
Christie (loan) - Success
Tansey - Failure
Maynard - Failure
GMS - Failure
Arnason - not played enough - Failure
May - Failure
Christie (loan) - Success
Stewart (loan) - Failure
Ball (loan) - Failure
Fan may argue the point about one or two, and I appreciate we're not quite half way through the season so writing some off from this season is perhaps harsh, but of his 8 signings this season only the continued loan of Christie appears to have been a successful signing.
Going back to last season, McInnes tried different things with his new signings and Aberdeen struggled in the league. It was only when he reverted to his tried and trusted tactics and personnel that they climbed the league again and finished second.
I think there are big question marks around McInnes' recruitment ability.
McInnes Transfer Record
posted on 4/12/17
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 4/12/17
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 4/12/17
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 4/12/17
We have slipped to British based player from best interceptions in Europe. Further segmenting the market in which the stats fit your point.
The stats fit the point to the fact he’s clearly the best passer in Britain and the best at interceptions in Europe.
Simple, using your flawed argument considering he’s bang average.
posted on 4/12/17
What is it we used to say to Mick?
When you are resorting to stats to make someone sound good you’ve already lost the argument
posted on 4/12/17
comment by NNH7 (U10730)
posted 24 minutes ago
We have slipped to British based player from best interceptions in Europe. Further segmenting the market in which the stats fit your point.
The stats fit the point to the fact he’s clearly the best passer in Britain and the best at interceptions in Europe.
Simple, using your flawed argument considering he’s bang average.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Apart from Brown has neither the best interception stats in Europe nor the best passing stats in Britain
While Tav has the best stats for a RB in Scotland.
posted on 4/12/17
Last season he most certainly did in the CL as I said earlier, would you like the proof.
posted on 4/12/17
This is the number 1 article on the site today.
That's nice.
posted on 4/12/17
comment by IvanGolacIsMagic 🐍 (U5291)
posted 27 seconds ago
This is the number 1 article on the site today.
That's nice.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You played it well, young Padawan
posted on 4/12/17
comment by RonaldVilliers (U21490)
posted 28 minutes ago
comment by NNH7 (U10730)
posted 24 minutes ago
We have slipped to British based player from best interceptions in Europe. Further segmenting the market in which the stats fit your point.
The stats fit the point to the fact he’s clearly the best passer in Britain and the best at interceptions in Europe.
Simple, using your flawed argument considering he’s bang average.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Apart from Brown has neither the best interception stats in Europe nor the best passing stats in Britain
While Tav has the best stats for a RB in Scotland.
Reply | Add Comment | Complain | Share
comment by NNH7 (U10730)
posted 26 minutes ago
Last season he most certainly did in the CL as I said earlier, would you like the proof.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ah, so not Europe like you said nor Britain but in the CL only
There sure are a lot of caveats to your point.
Mine didn't need any, best RB in Scotland.