Pep & Jose Transfers

comment by BO$$™ (U6401)
posted 55 minutes ago
Peps kinda lucky that he had a great core of players to work with when he joined. Kompany, Yaya, Fernandino, Aguero, Silva even Ottemendi to an extent.

Jose only really had De Gea the rest are lets face it pretty poor.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And the point is what he’s bought haven’t improved on an already pretty poor squad despite spending over £400m

comment by BO$$™ (U6401)
posted 33 minutes ago
comment by Erik (U21750)
posted 29 minutes ago
comment by BO$$™ (U6401)
posted 27 minutes ago
Peps kinda lucky that he had a great core of players to work with when he joined. Kompany, Yaya, Fernandino, Aguero, Silva even Ottemendi to an extent.

Jose only really had De Gea the rest are lets face it pretty poor.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Guardiola had De Bruyne and Sterling already too
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oops how can you forget about them. You could say if it wasnt for these WC core players he wouldnt have won the PL with ease. He's still be building a squad imo.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pep may only be in his third season but the club had been building towards his arrival long before he was even announced mid way before Pellegrinis last year.

Out of the 9 Utd players listed do you think any would get into a pep squad ?
Fred possible
Pogba not unless a significant upgrade in his workrate
Rest nowhere near good enough

The juiciest oranges are at the top of the tree.

How’s that orange tasting now Jose?

Mahrez £61m Will be Top Class
Laporte £58m Top class
Mendy £51m Top class
Walker £47m Top class
B Silva £45m Top class
Ederson £36m Top class
Danilo £27m Poor
Stones £50m Bang Average
Sane £45m Top class
Jesus £28m average so far
Gundogan £24m Almost a permacrock, wasted signing.
Bravo £16m One of the worst keepers in living memory
Nolito £16m Horrendous

£504m


Fred £53m Very average so far
Dalot £19m Great promise
Lukaku £76m Average
Matic £40m Average
Lindelof £31m Pathetic
Sanchez - Terrible
Pogba £94m Complete letdown
Mkhitaryan £37m very poor
Bailly £34m Decent

£384m

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
I reckon that is a bit more fair, from a neutral.

Fred £53m ?? probably poor
Dalot £19m poor
Lukaku £76m very poor
Matic £40m dreadful
Lindelof £31m pub player
Sanchez oh dear god
Pogba £94m bang average
Mkhitaryan £37m very poor
Bailly £34m dreadful


Would those players under Pep improve or have been better? I would like to think so.

comment by Hulk's little brother Yoda (U1250)
posted 25 minutes ago
Fred £53m ?? probably poor
Dalot £19m poor
Lukaku £76m very poor
Matic £40m dreadful
Lindelof £31m pub player
Sanchez oh dear god
Pogba £94m bang average
Mkhitaryan £37m very poor
Bailly £34m dreadful


Would those players under Pep improve or have been better? I would like to think so.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I don't know enough about Fred or Dalot yet so can't comment.

Lukaku wouldn't improve under Pep, just hasn't got it as a Pep player, likewise Matic.

Lindelof looks like a fish out of water in this league and I think he'd perform worse under Pep's demands.

Sanchez, possibly. I personally think he's going downhill.

Pogba would improve if he could cut out laziness, probably too much of a likeness to Yaya with Pep though.

Mkhitaryan is another that could have done better under Pep, definitely his type of player.

Bailly is raw and very rash, but Pep got Otamendi playing well and to his liking so maybe there's something there.

Mkhitaryan has improved at Arsenal ffs. Lukaku is the epitome of not a Pep player you need good control and passing to play Pep ball. The centre halfs are beyond improvement.

I just don't know where to start with the ridiculousness of the OP. Its a mess.

It certainly has got into a mess.