The overreaction on here

comment by Jinja Ninja (U19849)
posted 18 seconds ago
comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 1 minute ago
Very silly to suggest Bruno has been poor. His job is to create.

He’s created more than anyone in the premier league.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He was poor last game mate and rightly subbed imo


----------------------------------------------------------------------

Everyone has poor games.

But if you look at the season, his job is to create, he’s done that better than anyone (other than KdB possibly). Never mind his work rate, leadership etc. So it would be nonsense to say he has been poor.

comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 20 seconds ago
comment by Jinja Ninja (U19849)
posted 18 seconds ago
comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 1 minute ago
Very silly to suggest Bruno has been poor. His job is to create.

He’s created more than anyone in the premier league.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He was poor last game mate and rightly subbed imo


----------------------------------------------------------------------

Everyone has poor games.

But if you look at the season, his job is to create, he’s done that better than anyone (other than KdB possibly). Never mind his work rate, leadership etc. So it would be nonsense to say he has been poor.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

2 things

Firstly as daz said above I called Bruno being poor in last game because I felt he was. There was nothing more to it than that. It just seem to go ignored

Secondly I think it's clear to see his initial impact and this season are different. It's been not as good this season so far. And as I said earlier depends how you look at things.

Oh yeah and stats to.me don't show the whole picture. A pass to rashford deep in our half where rashford runs 3/4 of the pitch and scores is counted as an assist. Whereas a player making a run taking on 3 players and passing to a.n other who then makes a simple pass to the scorer gets nada

Jinja, I’m not dismissing your view on Bruno. I fully agree. I was saying you’re the only one I’ve seen give fair criticism. Nohlman seems to be Matth’s reference.

comment by Donny The King van de Beek (U10026)
posted 31 seconds ago
Jinja, I’m not dismissing your view on Bruno. I fully agree. I was saying you’re the only one I’ve seen give fair criticism. Nohlman seems to be Matth’s reference.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Yeah that post was a bit of a mess and unclear now I read back. Was trying to cram too many things in

I realise you agreed and were not dismissing my view

I forgive you too Ninja 🙃

But if you look at the season, his job is to create, he’s done that better than anyone (other than KdB possibly). Never mind his work rate, leadership etc.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Ozil's job was to create goals, which he was (on paper) one of the best in the world at doing, but football has evolved, and you have to offer more eg workrate, leadership etc as a CAM/CM these days imo.

comment by Jinja Ninja (U19849)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 20 seconds ago
comment by Jinja Ninja (U19849)
posted 18 seconds ago
comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 1 minute ago
Very silly to suggest Bruno has been poor. His job is to create.

He’s created more than anyone in the premier league.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He was poor last game mate and rightly subbed imo


----------------------------------------------------------------------

Everyone has poor games.

But if you look at the season, his job is to create, he’s done that better than anyone (other than KdB possibly). Never mind his work rate, leadership etc. So it would be nonsense to say he has been poor.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

2 things

Firstly as daz said above I called Bruno being poor in last game because I felt he was. There was nothing more to it than that. It just seem to go ignored

Secondly I think it's clear to see his initial impact and this season are different. It's been not as good this season so far. And as I said earlier depends how you look at things.

Oh yeah and stats to.me don't show the whole picture. A pass to rashford deep in our half where rashford runs 3/4 of the pitch and scores is counted as an assist. Whereas a player making a run taking on 3 players and passing to a.n other who then makes a simple pass to the scorer gets nada
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Yea nothing wrong with saying a player is poor in a game. Just silly to suggest Fernandes has been poor this season.

That’s a lot of waffle about assists, I was on about key chances created.

Not sure if your waffle is about a particular assist, from what I can recall two recent ones were Fernandes assist against Leipzig was a fantastic first time pass, again another great pass for Newcastle goal.

comment by AFCISMYTEAM (U14931)
posted 34 minutes ago
But if you look at the season, his job is to create, he’s done that better than anyone (other than KdB possibly). Never mind his work rate, leadership etc.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Ozil's job was to create goals, which he was (on paper) one of the best in the world at doing, but football has evolved, and you have to offer more eg workrate, leadership etc as a CAM/CM these days imo.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

In my opinion Bruno definitely offers both of those. Bruno is the closest thing to a captain United have.

Every player has better and worse runs of form. There's no harm in pointing that out. Going completely overboard in your criticism after a few bad games is a different story, but that's generally a minority and it's wrong to bundle anyone making a critical comment in with the drama queens.