or to join or start a new Discussion

9 Comments
Article Rating     Not Rated Yet

Emerson Royal

I hope we haven't made a mistake with this Emerson signing and he ends up flopping like Doherty.

Especially now reports Arsenal are negotiating for Tomiyasu.

I'm not an expert on either player but Tomiyasu looks much more composed and stronger defensively and Emerson comes across as cumbersome and not as good as I would have expected on the ball.

If we are reported to be paying £25-30m for Emerson and were reported to be unwilling to pay £22m for Tomiyasu it would indicate the Emerson is the better player.

But he has spent the past 2 seasons on loan at Betis so hardly a success at Barca either.

Thoughts?

posted on 31/8/21

Arsenal have signed Tomi apparently

posted on 31/8/21

Real is question is ….. are either better than Tanganga ?

posted on 31/8/21

Tanganga actually plays like a CB covering at full back. Good to throw on to keep it tight but he comes up well short further up the pitch. It looks like Emerson does the lot. With Doherty and Aurier in no man's land it was a position we needed. I'm not surprised by it at all.

posted on 31/8/21

I do not trust Tanganga as CB. I have seen him lose track of players too easily.

I havent seen him in a back 3 but that may be better suited to him. Right back he seems good as he is aggressive and mobile and only has to worry about players on one side of him. He's a good defensive RB like Davies is a LB but does offer a bit more going forward due to his athleticism. Much like Wan Bisaka at Utd

But to me it is clear that our team either needs one less DM to start games or more attacking and dangerous FBs. Reggie is fine at LB although seems to have less licence to attack right now. May be this is something we will develop as everyone settles in, Nuno included.

posted on 31/8/21

comment by Devonshirespur (U6316)
posted 4 minutes ago
I do not trust Tanganga as CB. I have seen him lose track of players too easily.

I havent seen him in a back 3 but that may be better suited to him. Right back he seems good as he is aggressive and mobile and only has to worry about players on one side of him. He's a good defensive RB like Davies is a LB but does offer a bit more going forward due to his athleticism. Much like Wan Bisaka at Utd

But to me it is clear that our team either needs one less DM to start games or more attacking and dangerous FBs. Reggie is fine at LB although seems to have less licence to attack right now. May be this is something we will develop as everyone settles in, Nuno included.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I trust Tanganga more at CB than I do Sanchez or Dier. If the kid stays fit he is a good defender.

posted on 31/8/21

comment by LukaBrasi COYS #FreePalestine (U22178)
posted 2 hours, 38 minutes ago
comment by Devonshirespur (U6316)
posted 4 minutes ago
I do not trust Tanganga as CB. I have seen him lose track of players too easily.

I havent seen him in a back 3 but that may be better suited to him. Right back he seems good as he is aggressive and mobile and only has to worry about players on one side of him. He's a good defensive RB like Davies is a LB but does offer a bit more going forward due to his athleticism. Much like Wan Bisaka at Utd

But to me it is clear that our team either needs one less DM to start games or more attacking and dangerous FBs. Reggie is fine at LB although seems to have less licence to attack right now. May be this is something we will develop as everyone settles in, Nuno included.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I trust Tanganga more at CB than I do Sanchez or Dier. If the kid stays fit he is a good defender.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thought he’s done well in the 1st 3 games

posted on 31/8/21

He was on loan at betis because they helped pay for him.

posted on 31/8/21

Emerson is much more of a traditional fullback than tomiyasu - he offers much more going forward. Tomiyasu is clearly a right back that you would keep in your own half and have make up a back 3 in possession (think what we did with Ben Davies under Mourinho.)

posted on 31/8/21

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 0 from 0 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available