or to join or start a new Discussion

52 Comments
Article Rating 5 Stars

De Gea V Ramires and Luiz

I notice a lot of rival fans give you guys stick over De Gea and you lot say alot he cannot be judged on a couple of mistakes.

But last season on the old 606 i seem to remember you lot aswell as numerous fans off other teams, coming onto our board taking the mick out of Ramires time after time ("Ramires 18m LOL" one of the very mature threads) and a lot of you seem to judge Luiz on one bad moment at Old Trafford yet tell us not to judge De Gea over a few mistakes.

For the record im not one of his haters ive rated the guy since he broke through at Athletico and im not one to "change my mind" because he has moved to a competitive rival.

But now you know how it feels so if we sign a player that struggles to adapt straight away or makes one or two mistakes please lay off them

posted on 5/10/11

ScsnNabanabay>de Gea

comment by Awesome (U8852)

posted on 5/10/11

De Gea> Szesny because i can spell his name

posted on 5/10/11

Carrol>sturridge

ask capello

posted on 5/10/11

Sturridge should be in that squad but he'l get his chance. Ran the show against Bolton last Sunday.

posted on 5/10/11

IMO i think schzesnygffg is better but only just. Still think De gea will be quality, but if you put sczenshybfbh in the the Man United he would look a lot better

posted on 5/10/11

by Mr Chelsea. (U3579)
agree, I dont understand what Capello sees in carrol, as a matter of fact I dont understand what Kenny sees in carrol. Imo Carrol is only suited to stoke.

Don mata
De Gea is better at distribution. GK with good distribution is essential for our style of play. I dont see SAF going for chesney even if he is available for free

posted on 5/10/11

Im not suggesting SAF should go for sczesneybfgjd but im saying if you stuck him in the United team, he would look a lot better than what is shown when he plays for Arsenal. And even when he plays for Arsenal he looks great

posted on 5/10/11

Don Mata

cant say for sure. different systems different requirements. I rate schzesny. I think schzesny, De Gea and Neuer are the best young keepers in the world but this constant De Gea bashing is tedious and boring.

posted on 5/10/11

Said this repeatedly but Sczenezy reminds me of Cech, excellent at dealing with 1 on 1s and shots in the box but much shakier on shots from outside the area

De Gea is similar, the slack he takes is more because of his price tag than anythinbg else

posted on 5/10/11

Personally I didn't rate Ramires when I saw him for Brazil in the Confederations Cup in 2009, I didn't rate him at the World Cup in 2010, and I thought he was poor for Chelsea in the first half of last season.

Since then, though, I think he has improved immeasurably and I think he is a very good player. I still think he needs a bit more time to fully adapt, but he seems to be a great prospect.

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 5 from 2 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available