The club is apparently considering offering Jannik a new contract. On the face of it, given how well he's performed this year and how he's proved to be an absolutely vital part of the Enzo revolution, this seems to make some sense. Although 32 before next season starts he's hopefully still got a few years left at the same, or similar, level of performance, but critically, his speed is likely only going in one direction.
The question I've got, which is one I've had all season since it became apparent that he was the surprise first choice at CB, is he good enough for the Premier League? Of course we have to get promoted first and that still isn't a given with some tough games to come, but it's looking promising at the moment. If we didn't get up and were consigned to the Championship for another year I wouldn't have any issue with retaining him.
Let's say for the sake of this discussion that we are promoted, which must surely be something the club have in mind in making this decision. He has been outstanding thus far, and even improving, given that he picked up a lot of yellow cards earlier, none recently, so he (and no doubt the rest of the defence) have found a way to minimise the impact of his lack of pace and him being slow to turn.
Here's the rub, in the higher league the back line is likely be consistently subject to a high press, executed really well by far superior, faster forwards/midfield. I doubt he's up to it, likely to not only have to resort to professional fouls earning yellow cards, but possibly even getting the occasional red if there isn't a covering defender. That's not a good place for the team to be in.
Put simply, I don't think he's good enough for the EPL, so I await the result of these contract talks with some trepidation. He might be worth keeping as a backup, but I doubt he would want to be in that situation. Nothing would please me more than being proved wrong on this by the way.
Thoughts?
Vestergaard
posted on 17/2/24
I don't think he's fast enough for the league he's currently operating in. He get's some great cover when beaten. His strength is his passing through the lines and positional sense and heading ability. Too slow for Premier league in my opinion, but might be handy to have around.
So, I think we pretty much agree and have same fears.
posted on 17/2/24
Well reasoned observations. I think you have to look beyond individual abilities; in the current climate it’s more about how the back four and their back-ups perform as a unit. Everyone at the club will be well aware of his shortcomings and make provision for them in the rest of the unit. If they can keep the balance right, there’s no reason why it shouldn’t work next season.
posted on 17/2/24
comment by old warwick fox (U11640)
posted 3 hours ago
Well reasoned observations. I think you have to look beyond individual abilities; in the current climate it’s more about how the back four and their back-ups perform as a unit. Everyone at the club will be well aware of his shortcomings and make provision for them in the rest of the unit. If they can keep the balance right, there’s no reason why it shouldn’t work next season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Exactly OWF, lets not forget until Rodgers destroyed him along with the rest of the squad he was a Premier League player along with being a regular Denmark player.
I have now worries over him than any other Player being good enough, well actually that's not true, I think Coady has been very poor in the few times we've seen him and if he was going to be a replacement for Vestergaard I'd be more worried.
posted on 17/2/24
He's playing well but sadly too slow to be considered in premier league.
Think premier forwards like Salah would show him up badly.
Squad player at best.
posted on 18/2/24
Yawwwnnnn. I just heard a bugle in the distance. Fox-hunting season is open for business.