No shame

comment by Winston (U16525)
posted 59 minutes ago
Funny, listening to the Rest is Football podcast and there's broad agreement that the penalty could have been given but it was probably not enough to be overturned.

I guess those guys are 'insane' as well.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
Why is insane in quotation marks? Did somebody use that word here? If so, I don't think it was me.

Also, why do you think this supports your argument? If it's true that's what they said then they're also admitting it was a pen by saying "the penalty could have been given..."

That suggests it was a penalty and they're just being politically correct, and backs up what I said, not what you said.

comment by Winston (U16525)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Mambadamus (U1282)
posted 43 seconds ago
comment by Winston (U16525)
posted 2 hours, 59 minutes ago
comment by Mambadamus (U1282)
posted 29 minutes ago
comment by FieldsofAnfieldRd (U18971)
posted 44 minutes ago
"I also said McAllister was clearly cheating with his reaction"

Clearly

Weird how you're the only one with a bee in your bonnet about this.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Unsurprisingly, out of all that incident, Mac cheating is the one thing that's "clear" to Winston and not subjective at all. Makes sense.

He's clearly the one with a bee in his bonnet.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

You think he could have been in so much pain to justify the way he was behaving?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
We don't know how much pain he was in. You on the other hand are "certain" that he was exaggerating. That goes directly against your own teachings. The only certain things is that it proves bias on your part. He must have been in at least some pain as he got studded in the ribs. There is not a chance anyone but Mac can be "certain" about how much pain he was in, leave alone some dude watching on TV.

Sometimes you're a walking talking contradiction.
----------------------------------------------------------------------



Genuinely laughing that you think he could have been in that much pain to justify that reaction.

You really will say absolutely anything.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm laughing you think you know for certain how much pain he was in. He got studded in the ribs, even a short scraping notion could possibly cause a lot of pain. When you watch fights does every knockout come from a haymaker?

Keep justifying it.

Then, when you next see Bruno writhing in agony when we all know he's faking it, remember what you said about this incident.

It's laughable.

You will say anything. Anything at all.

comment by Winston (U16525)
posted 24 minutes ago
Keep justifying it.

Then, when you next see Bruno writhing in agony when we all know he's faking it, remember what you said about this incident.

It's laughable.

You will say anything. Anything at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That's a stoopid take which I didn't expect from you. If Bruno does that I will judge that situation on it's merits. My decision will not be based on what I decided the last time but based on facts. If it's possible to my eyes that the contact could have been enough to cause the pain I will give him the benefit of doubt, no doubt.

You decision will most likely be based on your bias.

No one can seriously watch that yesterday - Mcallister rolling around as if he's in agony because of what would be at worst a scratch on his chest, before getting up to be absolutely fine for the corner (once he realised VAR wasn't taking action) - and concluding that he wasn't faking it... well, they've either biased or beyond help.

Of course there are times where we think a player is milking it but then it turns out they're really hurt. This wasn't one of them.

Nit everyone applies bias to every situation. Again you don't know what I would do.

When Mac saw they weren't giving it he got up because there was little time left and we needed to win.

What a hero... to go from writhing agony to playing on in such a short space of time.

comment by Winston (U16525)
posted 1 minute ago
What a hero... to go from writhing agony to playing on in such a short space of time.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Exactly.

Almost as heroic as Bruno vs Fulham.

2 days later and Winston is still.arguing the toss over an inconsequential decision in aatvh that has nothing to do with United, what a sad act.

If only he made the same effort with his own team.