Player Ratings 23/24

comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 3 minutes ago
Generous with Onana too.

He started getting way too much praise for simply starting to resemble a competent goalkeeper in the second half of the season, should be starting his rating from that point at minus 10 for single handed knocking us out of the CL and costing us countless points in the league.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Agreed. He is rated on the Maguire Metric.

Andre Onana 5

Diogo Dalot 7

Aaron Wan-Bissaka 5

Raphael Varane 6

Lisandro Martinez 6

Harry Maguire 6.5

Victor Lindelof 4

Jonny Evans 7.5

Willy Kambwala 6

Luke Shaw 4

Kobbie Mainoo 9

Casemiro 3

Scott McTominay 7.5

Sofyan Amrabat 5

Christian Eriksen 4

Mason Mount 4

Bruno Fernandes 8

Antony 3

Alejandro Garnacho 8

Marcus Rashford 3

Amad 7

Anthony Martial 1

Rasmus Hojlund 8.5

Andre Onana 5
Diogo Dalot 6
Aaron Wan-Bissaka 5
Raphael Varane 5
Lisandro Martinez N/R
Harry Maguire 6
Victor Lindelof 4
Jonny Evans 6
Willy Kambwala N/R
Luke Shaw N/R
Kobbie Mainoo 7
Casemiro 4
Scott McTominay 5
Bruno Fernandes 6
Antony 2
Alejandro Garnacho 7.5
Marcus Rashford 3
Amad N/R
Anthony Martial 2
Rasmus Hojlund 6.5

I have given N/R for those that didn't play enough to warrant one.

comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 31 minutes ago
Generous with Onana too.

He started getting way too much praise for simply starting to resemble a competent goalkeeper in the second half of the season, should be starting his rating from that point at minus 10 for single handed knocking us out of the CL and costing us countless points in the league.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah this.

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 4 minutes ago
Andre Onana 5
Diogo Dalot 6
Aaron Wan-Bissaka 5
Raphael Varane 5
Lisandro Martinez N/R
Harry Maguire 6
Victor Lindelof 4
Jonny Evans 6
Willy Kambwala N/R
Luke Shaw N/R
Kobbie Mainoo 7
Casemiro 4
Scott McTominay 5
Bruno Fernandes 6
Antony 2
Alejandro Garnacho 7.5
Marcus Rashford 3
Amad N/R
Anthony Martial 2
Rasmus Hojlund 6.5

I have given N/R for those that didn't play enough to warrant one.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pretty much why I marked Martinez/Shaw/Amad/Kambwala low scores

Onana 4
Dalot 6
AWB 4
Varane 6
Martinez 3
Maguire 5
Evans 7
Lindelof 3
Shaw 3
Kambwala 2
Mainoo 5.5
Casemiro 4
Amrabat 3
Mctominay 5
Eriksen 3
Mount 1
Bruno 7
Antony 3
Garnacho 7
Rashford 4
Amad 4.5
Hojlund 6

Also have to rate players relative to their age/experience/situation too, hard to be fair and do it as a blanket rule for them all.

For me Evans has to be up there with the best as he couldn’t have done more for us considering he was supposed to just be training to join someone else and see his career out.

comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 1 minute ago
Also have to rate players relative to their age/experience/situation too, hard to be fair and do it as a blanket rule for them all.

For me Evans has to be up there with the best as he couldn’t have done more for us considering he was supposed to just be training to join someone else and see his career out.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Evans has been pretty solid given his age, I was gobsmacked when we brought him back but he certainly hasn’t been the disaster I thought he might be after watching him for Leicester last season

comment by Brian Gittins (U1449)
posted 1 hour, 3 minutes ago
comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 1 minute ago
Also have to rate players relative to their age/experience/situation too, hard to be fair and do it as a blanket rule for them all.

For me Evans has to be up there with the best as he couldn’t have done more for us considering he was supposed to just be training to join someone else and see his career out.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Evans has been pretty solid given his age, I was gobsmacked when we brought him back but he certainly hasn’t been the disaster I thought he might be after watching him for Leicester last season
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If we actually played football how I thought Ten Hag was going to set us up when he came from Ajax then Evans would’ve struggled a lot.

Given we choose to set up with zero midfield though and our defenders have been balls to the wall most of the year, he’s been good in the box.

How on earth of people rating Maguire over Varane?