I'll try to make this as short and as un-repetitve as most of the other posts. I've been a bit quiet while reading the general opinions on the board since the weekend. The board is definitely divided between the Pro AVB, the Anti-AVB, the undecided, the annoyed and Mr Capello. Kinda like our dressing room and I'm guessing Mikel is the Mr Capello in there.
ON AVB
He's a brilliant manager. Very intelligent and tactically sound, willing to take risks, great speaker(this has swayed a few fans) and reasonably good in the transfer market. He has been very naive thus far in a few areas;
Trusting Lampard at the start of the season and after media pressure.
Replying the media, should totally give them nothing to work with whenever possible.
Handling Alex and Anelka(should have just let them go in Jan without publicizing the transfer request).
These are understandable mistakes though. I can't fault his team selection most times. I felt Essien would have been better against Napoli rather than Raul and he should have stuck with his guts and not played Lampard at all. Essien on for Malouda at the start of the 2nd half with Rami moving to the right and Studge moving to the left leaving Mata in the hole.
I really doubt his abilities in rebuilding a squad of this magnitude though especially with his 'experimental' backroom staff. No member of his team has significant rebuilding experience so it could be quite difficult but more on this after I talk about the players.
ON PLAYER POWER
Unacceptable at any club and should be destroyed quickly. Management should always have all the power ala City and Tevez. Lampard has relentlessly said that their(the old guard's) past performances for this club means they should play the majority of the games. This mentality brings failure in any system and if Frank can't accept fighting for his place, he should be out(in the reserves or out) ASAP, legend or not.
CONCLUSION
If AVB had experience in rebuilding, it would have been a no brainer but he doesn't. Look at it this way, If you have a dislocated arm, you can;
1. choose the easy option and leave it untouched but suffer long term(fire AVB and get in Benitez or Capello short term),
2. choose the difficult and painful option ie force the arm back into place and enjoy long term but suffer short term.(sack players , fail to qualify for CL short term but come back bigger and better)
Warning: if the physiotherapist isn't too good, you could break the arm in the process.Ours (AVB) has shown great potential but is still unproven.
Chelsea in my opinion cannot give more power to these players by firing another manager(albeit one not really assured to do a good job). The players in question have very little left in the tank making the decision easier. We have to risk breaking our arm to relocate our shoulder with a potentially fantastic physiotherapist(AVB) and even though we could leave the arm and let it serve us to the best of it's now limited abilities, that is unadvisable.
Chelsea- The Dislocated Arm
posted on 23/2/12
posted on 23/2/12
We could also find a better physiotherapist at great cost in hard times(fire AVB with FFP looming and get Benitez or Capello). This doesn't mean you still wouldn't break the arm even though the chances are less. Its also possible that before you get this physiotherapist in, the damage to the arm could have spread to other more important parts of the body meaning the therapist has greater work to do with less resources in hard times.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
The analogies are probably getting a bit crazy. But I hope you get me.
posted on 23/2/12
"tactically sound"
Are you taking the pišš?
posted on 23/2/12
Sorry OP but IMO this is blind loyalism.
Liverpool fans used to be like this with Rafa and we all laughed and said how deluded they were and in the end we were all right.
AVB will be no different. He actually has startling similarities to Rafa and Wenger IMO.
10 years time he'll be a better manager. He'll learn from this job and so will we
posted on 23/2/12
tactically sound
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is from watching his Porto team numerous times last season and watching a few tactical changes he's made this year. Its a pity the players feel he's trying to 'overcoach them' else we'd have seen more of this tactical ability.
posted on 23/2/12
Sorry OP but IMO this is blind loyalism.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Wrong. i do not trust AVB with the rebuilding job at all. I just feel he's the lesser of two risks.
1. Bowing to player power and delayed revolution.
2. Leaving the wrong man in charge of our revolution and eventually ending up like the Gooners or the Scousers.
I prefer option 2 cos we could also end up like Barca in two or three years if we are lucky.
posted on 23/2/12
Are you taking the pišš?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Replaced Meireles with Moutinho, turned Moutinho into a Xavi-esque figure at Porto
- Converted Hulk into a RW, allowing for Porto's conservative RB to remain back why'll Perreira offered the threat from the left.
- Gave Guarin the Meireles role
Those three tactical transformations won Porto their treble last year. God for bid he should tell our players how he'd like them to be played, they might just throw a hissy fit
posted on 23/2/12
Avb came here with the reputation of being a great tactician, doubt that would change in the space of 9 months.
posted on 23/2/12
Now. Now. Now. Now. Now. Now.
Tomorrow
posted on 23/2/12
Avb came here with the reputation of being a great tactician, doubt that would change in the space of 9 months.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Very well said.