or to join or start a new Discussion

53 Comments
Article Rating 3 Stars

is pepe that good?

don't get me wrong, at the least he must have some good man management skills and everything else above average, but lets be honest, he's only inherited one of the best football teams ever. He's also had a lot of money to spend as well as a great academy. His tactics are never going to change due to barca's philosophy. I'm sure he's made a few changes but all he really has to do is pick the squad

people often criticize JM for only being good because he's spent loads, which is ridiculous as he not only got a name for himself by getting a small portugese team who's name I keep on forgetting into europe for the first time, and somehow won the CL with porto. All due respect but I can never remember a time where the portugese league was that dominant a force in the CL. He then moved to chelsea and won everything but the CL, and then in a time where italian football was in decline he won the CL again with Inter (don't think anyone was expecting that until he did it) and could possibly win it with Madrid, who he is likely to win la liga, which means he'll have reached 4 leagues in different countries, something only he has done. Even though I'm an arsenal fan and I don't like his style I don't get how people can fail to acknowledge him. He's the only manager I'm scared of arsenal facing.

Main reason I'm making this article is because I don't get why Pep gets so much more praise than JM even though Pep has had everything handed to him on a plate, he hasn't really had to manage an average/bellow average team to prove his capabilities. He's litterally having a real life version of football manager right now. JM on the other hand has started with not a lot and earned every ridiculous transfer budget he's ever had

comment by Tu Meke (U3732)

posted on 17/3/12

he only employs them against barca tbf. against other teams they are superb at times.

posted on 17/3/12

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 17/3/12

not sure you're really arguing the case for pep properly there quebecelt...

posted on 17/3/12

Mr. Chelsea, your ex-manager is a whining little man who tries to influence the refs with his incessant moaning.

comment by steryd (U12151)

posted on 17/3/12

And your point is?

posted on 17/3/12

Obviously I don't like him. That's about it.

posted on 17/3/12

quebecelt - i think they're both good managers - you cannot questions mourinho's record of winning a league title in every country he's been in and he's won 2 cl's with two different clubs. obviously he has a way of doing things. some may not like it. i dont think he's all that negative. only when he has to be ultra negative then he will play that type of football like against barcelona for example but if you watch their football against the rest of the league, its far from boring

also on the diving issue, i suggest you look at some barcelona players. they can dive and feign injury and exxaggerate contact as much as any of mourinho's men

i like pep because of the football he's got barcelona playing. its pretty much perfect football and he's won something like 13 trophies in 4 years of managing them. ridiculous record.

posted on 17/3/12

Mourinho is a much better manager than Pep Guardiola in my opinion but I do have one criticism to make about Mourinho that he will never be a long-term manager of any club unlike Ferguson or Wenger or Shankley or Paisley.

Guardiola has the most talented team which consists of many players who have grown playing with each other their entire life.

posted on 17/3/12

Mr. as I posted earlier, Pep was the Barca youth coach for 4/5 years before becoming 1st team manager.
He had a LOT to do with building that team.
2 different men 2 different styles and 2 different sets of circumstances.
Wait a minute I don't like Chelsea either.

Have a nice weekend.

posted on 18/3/12

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 3 from 6 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available