or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 15 comments are related to an article called:

anyone else

Page 1 of 1

posted on 1/7/11

RH...Great player, but in top 3???? What about Alfredo Di Stephano, Pele, John Charles, Jimmy Greaves, Marco Van Basten, Rivelino, Cruyff, Best, Eddie Gray, Maradona, Ronaldo, Ronaldo, Messi, Didi, Beckanbaur, Brian Robson, Hadgi, Zola, Platini, ZiZu, Hidgegutti, Kopa, know what I mean?

posted on 1/7/11

All of them players you listed are world class. Especially Maradona,Pele,Zizu,Gray and Di Stefano. But In my view the top 3 players of all time are Maradona,Pele,Puskas. Messi can easily eclipse all them though if he continues.

posted on 1/7/11

Maradona= 1 footed couldn't head a ball couldn't tackle wasn't fast, midget!

Puskas= 1 footed, couldn't head a ball couldn't tackle wasn't fast, midget!

John Charles= 2 footed, great header, great tackler, fast, goal scorer, attacker and defender, giant, voted best foreigner to play in Italy ahead of Maradona.

posted on 1/7/11

Pele
Cruyff
Maradona
Zidane
Messi
Best
Puskas
Florian Albert
Van Basten
Bremner


In that order

And what about

Peter Haddock?

Eh?


posted on 1/7/11

George Best eclipses the lot.

posted on 1/7/11

Chorleywhite

Aye, in your opinion, but on occasions Paul Reaney 'eclipsed' him!

posted on 1/7/11

Eric,surely the original Ronaldo gotta be up there?

posted on 1/7/11

Ronaldo MacDonaldo?

posted on 1/7/11

Eric.... You can not be serious!!!

Florian Albert wasn't even the best forward in the Hungarian team that he played in, that honour went to Ferenc Bene who I saw down at ER for Ujpest Dozsa and you've put him ahead of Van Basten who might be the greatest of all time and where's John Charles who Shanks said was the best player he ever saw.

posted on 1/7/11

Yes,Ronaldo Macdonaldo one of the greatest strikers ever

posted on 1/7/11

original koppite

You see dear fellow, this is where opinions come in. Just because Bill Shankly liked a player does not make me like him.

I met John Charles, great man, great player. I never saw him play.

In your opinion Van Basten might be the greatest player of all time, there are many would disagree.

I put my choices down. You're entitled to your opinion on my choices.

posted on 1/7/11

Best goal ever-Maradona
Best player ever-Maradona
Best player ever never to win world cup-Messi
Most underated player ever-Cafu
Best manager ever-Don Revie

posted on 1/7/11

Eric... Well I'm pleased you look at it that way because I've already expressed my opinion and I would hate to offend you.

Not much gets past me and it has struck me you prefer succinctity so in a nutshell...YOU HAVEN'T A SCOOBY!!!

posted on 1/7/11

Just cannot see Argentina winning the world cup, think it'll be Germany for next 2 or 3

posted on 1/7/11

original koppite

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment