or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 25 comments are related to an article called:

Players to Leave the Club?

Page 1 of 1

posted on 30/5/12

Replace Doni with Jones, and add Gulacsi, Darby, Wilson, Spearing and Ecclestone to the potential exit list.

posted on 30/5/12

Why Doni? He seems happy enough.

posted on 30/5/12

Kuyt doesn't get a sad face. I'll give it a go.

Kuyt

posted on 30/5/12

I wouldn't be too fussed if Kuyt left. Within a year or so his value will start to plummet due to his age, so I can see the sense in cashing in on him now and concentrating on the next generation.

posted on 30/5/12

Charlie "I look like Budda" Adam.
Jay "Chicken without a head" Spearing.
Maxi "I'm a bench warmer" Rodriguez.
Dirk "My second touch is a tackle" Kuyt.
Jonjo "I'm over rated" Shelvey.

Good riddance,

posted on 30/5/12

Aurelio yes,
Kuyt probably, as he keeps saying he has loads of clubs interested in him, wouldn't need to do that if he was staying.
Aqua, sounds lkie he wants gone, so nothing we can do about it unfortunately.
Doni, unless he wants to go why get rid, not going to get much better that will sit on the bench.
Pacheco, not sure think we need to move on from that wasn't to be.
Maxi, probably be gone as age and not getting enough game time.

i would add Spearing to that list, i know some will say but 3rd choice blah blah but he isn't 3rd choice now and he is carp so get rid for me, i think he is useless anyway.

comment by Biglaa (U5954)

posted on 30/5/12

PPF, I'd like to see Wilson stay. Aurelio has already left as far as I'm aware. Hopefully not his annual, leave then be brought back by the next manager!

posted on 30/5/12

Gulacsi out on loan again, Ecclestone might well be given another chance

Spearing has to go.

posted on 30/5/12

Downing.

posted on 30/5/12

Wasn't sure whether to add Spearing or not but he will now forever be in Shelvey's shadow in the centre mid role.

posted on 30/5/12

Downing and Adam have only been here a year, and a good squad is vital for a succesful team! We have to give our signings from last year a chance to blend in, and not revamp all over again!

posted on 30/5/12

Carroll? No place in a tippy-tappy team for a long ball merchant.

posted on 30/5/12

Anyway also wanting Jonjo out cannot judge potential when they see it. He looks just as promising as Lampard or Gerrard did at 20!

posted on 30/5/12

*Anyone

posted on 30/5/12

Joe Cole and Aquilani for sure. I personally would keep Maxi.
Kuyt, Spearing and Adam all to leave.

posted on 30/5/12

comment by Resurrection is Nigh (U14154)
posted 5 minutes ago
Charlie "I look like Budda" Adam.
Jay "Chicken without a head" Spearing.
Maxi "I'm a bench warmer" Rodriguez.
Dirk "My second touch is a tackle" Kuyt.
Jonjo "I'm over rated" Shelvey.

Good riddance,
------------------------------------------------------------
Bit harsh. In fact no, more than a bit harsh, a lot harsh.

I'll give it a try:

Charlie 'fair enough I'm bad but what the hell does my apparent likeness to a religious idol have to do with anything' Adam

Jay 'loyal servant who plays well and may lack the skill for Liverpool but is certainly not a headless chicken' Spearing

Maxi 'I was underplayed by Kenny despite scoring in almost every game I played in and I'm still hugely talented, perhaps one of the most talented players in the Liverpool squad at present and in what way is the fact that I warm the bench my fault' Rodriguez

Dirk 'I've scored over 70 goals for Liverpool, I've been here since 2006, I put in more for my team than any player in the Premiership, I was classed as having a bad year despite scoring against Man United and in the Carling Cup final, I'm still one of the best players in this team when played in the correct position and I don't deserve this sort of disrespect after years of loyal service to the club' Kuyt

Jonjo 'I'm up and coming and what's been seen of me in the first team so far has been impressive and how is it my fault if I'm rated so highly' Shelvey

There. Fixed.

posted on 30/5/12

Downing and Adam have only been here a year, and a good squad is vital for a succesful team!
========================================
Look at Downing's career. He has always been a maybe player who never delivered at the big stage. We can still make some money on him and move him on as he will not take us forward.

posted on 30/5/12

This list would be harsh, but if we are to get to the next level then these players need to be moved on to accomodate new talent :

Jones - wages can be better utilised
Carragher - Coaching role
Wilson - won't cut it
Spearing - doesn't cut it
Aquilani - doesn't want to be here
Shelvey - season long loan
Henderson - "passanger"
Adam - too slow and clumsy
Cole - see Adam
Maxi - wages can be better utilised
Kuyt - see Maxi
Downing - not good enough
Pacheco - doesn't cut it

Like i said harsh, but if you raise the best part of £25m plus in funds & wages from that, give Rodgers an extra £30m kitty and he would still have this to work with:

Reina, Doni, Kelly, Johnson, Coates, Skrtel, Agger, Enrique, Lucas, Gerrard, Bellamy, Suarez, Carroll, Robinson, Suso, Sterling.

I realise it's not footy manager but you did ask who should leave

posted on 30/5/12

Would love to see Suso, Sterling and Robinson playing more.

Still undecided on Flanagan...

posted on 30/5/12

Cant argue with that scouseking.

posted on 30/5/12

Flanagan > Robinson if you ask me.

posted on 30/5/12

Henderson will improve next year under Rodgers imo. He is the king of short simple passes

posted on 30/5/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 30/5/12

'Good enough for LFC'

That phrase would be well scrutinised by opposing fans.

posted on 30/5/12

Scouse King5.
Out of that lot you mentioned, the two I would definitely keep are Downing and Henderson.
Downing is a very good player, however he must be instructed to stay on the left and not move, just travel up and down that side more often than Jordan's knickers go up and down on a Saturday night.
Henderson has performed best in the centre, he's only young and hill run all day.
Shelvey when he toughens up is going to be one hell of player thats for sure. I would definitely keep him over Adam, as he's already the player Adam isn't or will ever be.

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment