I think you should put this on a neutral board.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Yeah I know which is why I asked for multiboard but I don't know what neutral board I can put this on with them actually caring?
The England board? Not sure it gets many hits?
Plus more people troll the united board anyway so should reach a larger audience.
I do not rate John Terry as a defender. Carvalho made him look good. He's always caught out of position, that's why you see him make so many last ditch tackles.
You would think after the way the germans embaraased him at the last world cup, he would call it a day.
Would take Rio any day of the week
Vidic has carried Rio for years. If Vidic or Smalling had stayed fit I honestly reckon United would have won the league. Rio is shockingly bad these days
Rio was a rock for us at the back, Smalling was fit but found himself behind Evans in the pecking order.
I think JT is in better form than Ferdie, but Ferdie would play given all the injuries we have got. Has JT said he wont play with JT full stop?
lol Sorry has Ferdie said he wont play with JT full stop
being completely honest,rio ferdinand and john terry are both over rated ,its just you english people who rate them otherwise they have been carried through out their careers by defenders playing alongside them e.g:Carvalho/Vidic
You're right this has already been done, and Terry won:
http://www.ja606.co.uk/articles/viewArticle/117291
But your poll was different as it wasn't just a straight choice between Ferdinand and Terry. Some of the votes for the other players may not have gone to Terry.
That's a fair point I suppose, but with that many more voting for Terry than Ferdinand across different boards, I still can't see the votes from others being enough to put Ferdinand in the lead, especially if you have a 'Neither' option as well.
I mean you've posted this on the United board and Rio is only slightly in the lead here.
OP
Your rating system won't work. These types never do.
You are best just asking for one word answers and counting up who gets what at the end.
But why? The people who have voted 3 stars would have just said terry, the people who voted 5 stars would have said Ferdinand and the people who voted 1 star would have just said neither so what difference would it make?
Spurtle I only put this on the united board as I'm a united fan and I know more people come of this board than any others. Plus I couldn't post it on more than 1 board.
Rio should retire now and stick two fingers up at Woy and the FA, and just concentrate on United.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
I want terry to get injured in the next few days and then Rio announce his retirement as the FA try to get him back.
I vote for Rio
And if he's not available then I still vote Rio
Then Rio again
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Rio or Terry? (poll)
Page 1 of 1
posted on 4/6/12
I think you should put this on a neutral board.
posted on 4/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 4/6/12
Yeah I know which is why I asked for multiboard but I don't know what neutral board I can put this on with them actually caring?
posted on 4/6/12
The England board? Not sure it gets many hits?
posted on 4/6/12
Plus more people troll the united board anyway so should reach a larger audience.
posted on 4/6/12
I do not rate John Terry as a defender. Carvalho made him look good. He's always caught out of position, that's why you see him make so many last ditch tackles.
You would think after the way the germans embaraased him at the last world cup, he would call it a day.
Would take Rio any day of the week
posted on 4/6/12
Embarassed'''
posted on 4/6/12
Vidic has carried Rio for years. If Vidic or Smalling had stayed fit I honestly reckon United would have won the league. Rio is shockingly bad these days
posted on 4/6/12
Rio was a rock for us at the back, Smalling was fit but found himself behind Evans in the pecking order.
posted on 4/6/12
I think JT is in better form than Ferdie, but Ferdie would play given all the injuries we have got. Has JT said he wont play with JT full stop?
posted on 4/6/12
lol Sorry has Ferdie said he wont play with JT full stop
posted on 4/6/12
being completely honest,rio ferdinand and john terry are both over rated ,its just you english people who rate them otherwise they have been carried through out their careers by defenders playing alongside them e.g:Carvalho/Vidic
posted on 4/6/12
You're right this has already been done, and Terry won:
http://www.ja606.co.uk/articles/viewArticle/117291
posted on 4/6/12
But your poll was different as it wasn't just a straight choice between Ferdinand and Terry. Some of the votes for the other players may not have gone to Terry.
posted on 4/6/12
That's a fair point I suppose, but with that many more voting for Terry than Ferdinand across different boards, I still can't see the votes from others being enough to put Ferdinand in the lead, especially if you have a 'Neither' option as well.
I mean you've posted this on the United board and Rio is only slightly in the lead here.
posted on 4/6/12
OP
Your rating system won't work. These types never do.
You are best just asking for one word answers and counting up who gets what at the end.
posted on 4/6/12
But why? The people who have voted 3 stars would have just said terry, the people who voted 5 stars would have said Ferdinand and the people who voted 1 star would have just said neither so what difference would it make?
posted on 4/6/12
Spurtle I only put this on the united board as I'm a united fan and I know more people come of this board than any others. Plus I couldn't post it on more than 1 board.
posted on 4/6/12
Rio should retire now and stick two fingers up at Woy and the FA, and just concentrate on United.
posted on 4/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 4/6/12
I want terry to get injured in the next few days and then Rio announce his retirement as the FA try to get him back.
posted on 4/6/12
I vote for Rio
And if he's not available then I still vote Rio
Then Rio again
Page 1 of 1