or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 76 comments are related to an article called:

What's worse....

Page 3 of 4

posted on 7/6/12

Valencia's Right Foot (U11781)
posted 13 seconds ago
comment by BusbysBabes (U9083)

This was the 2010-11 season, Park was one our most stand out performers and Valencia had a fantastic end to the season after coming back from his injury. I agree with Scholes though, but he picked Valencia out because of that CL final. He thinks every player should be on form for every game, he's a mug.


He talks garbage, but Park has been phased out, Scholes was brought back from retirement and his prediction of Evra's poor season was correct.

You only need to look at the signings he wanted to see he is a plank, but he is a genuine fan.

posted on 7/6/12

Sorry was it the end of the 10/11 season or begging of?

posted on 7/6/12

The end. Remember Park's performances in the CL games? The Chelsea game at OT? And yet he wanted him out, I still think Park can be a reliable squad player if he's given a run of games. And he wanted Valencia out for not performing in the CL final.

posted on 7/6/12

Obviously Valencia out was a ridiculous idea.

Park, whilst having played well in the big games, it turns out he was right, he was truly shocking this season, so his opinion was justified. And I don't believe a run f games has anything to do with it, he used to always be rested until the big games and would come in and do well.

posted on 7/6/12

Park is only 30, I couldn't have predicted him declining this quick because he had a decent season that year. Looks like he has been declining, but still can be a decent squad player.

posted on 7/6/12

He doesn't use logic in his posts, I mean look:

IN
De Gea
Modric
Sneijder
Nasri
Benzema

Promoted:
Welbeck
Pogba
Tunnicliffe
W Keane
Morrison

These players he wants to promote, where the hell are they going to get the game time with the ridiculous players he wants signed like Nasri and Benzema?

posted on 7/6/12

Park is only 30, I couldn't have predicted him declining this quick because he had a decent season that year. Looks like he has been declining, but still can be a decent squad player.

------

Bit hard to say a player is declining when he's only managed 1 game since Jan and that game being against city of all teams!

posted on 7/6/12

RSC his legs have gone, he doesn't have that workhorse ability in him anymore and pretty much looks lost on the pitch. He's given the ball away countless of times, the only game I think he was alright in was the 5-0 thumping of Wigan.

comment by RB&W (U2335)

posted on 7/6/12

it turned out the CP was right in some extent though, as Sneidjer said the deal was very close to happening.
***

no he wasn't.....it was the fact that he claimed on numerous occasions, that 'through his connections' he knew it was a 'done deal' and that an announcement was to be made on whateverday, .... that got people's backs up. Same with Nasri.

posted on 7/6/12

Has Carickature been banned?

Wondered where he was

TBH I don't think it would be long the way he arrived on the scene instantly accusing me Vidicchin and a couple of others of thinking we own the place lol

He even created a thread about it. I was like wtf????

comment by VCG © (U13761)

posted on 7/6/12

I was thinking the other day where had he gone, so he was banned ? He did seem to have some issues.

posted on 7/6/12

It's a bit harsh on Park, saying that he is declining. He hasn't played many games and he always does better sfter a run of games. He is rested before a big game but before the short rest he has a run of games and is match fit. That can't be said about him last season. He hasn' declined. Just a bad season for him.

posted on 7/6/12

It's a bit harsh on Park, saying that he is declining. He hasn't played many games and he always does better sfter a run of games. He is rested before a big game but before the short rest he has a run of games and is match fit. That can't be said about him last season. He hasn' declined. Just a bad season for him.

posted on 7/6/12

That carrickature is a sausage too.

posted on 7/6/12

I think carrickature's obsession with Carrick should have also been included in the main article.

posted on 7/6/12

VRF

-----

If Park had not been out for the most part of the second half of the season, we both could have given him a better assessment of his form.

Don't forget saf must have seen something positive in him during training for him to have thrown Park in against City, not forgetting, that was the only game he played this year.

In saying that, i'd be suprised if he'll be with us for the start of the new campaign!

posted on 7/6/12

To be fair to slm he's simply been saying why he'd like to see Modric come to united and why he thinks he's a good player, albeit repeatedly, but cp was constantly peddling all sorts of nonsense about his sources and inside info about Wesley arriving imminently as if it was essentially guaranteed.

I'd rather someone posted their opinions about a player on a sports forum, even if frequently, rather than make a load of stuff up to sound like you have secret reliable sources

posted on 7/6/12

CP was more annoying, but if SLM keeps it up throughout the summer and then says 'we should have got him' whenever we fail to win a game next season, he may overtake him.

I rate Modric. No way in hell would I spend £40m on him, but he plays in the deep playmaker position which we could strengthen. At least SLM understands Modric's role, even if he does bang on about him quite a bit.

posted on 7/6/12

Don't forget saf must have seen something positive in him during training for him to have thrown Park in against City, not forgetting, that was the only game he played this year.
--------------
He played in 3 Europa league games (the 3 we lost), Newcastle 9(lost)and also Stoke at the end of Jan (won) but still, hardly enough to warrant a place v City

posted on 7/6/12

I think slm is getting much criticism in this case largely because many united fans don't seem to rate Modric. This is ensuring more people get annoyed because slm does rate him. In my kind not on the same scale as cps annoying articles about his sources and using public info to tel us things we already know as if they are something secret and new.

posted on 7/6/12

Pea

The guy constantly berates Sir Alex and a fair few United players

When United play badly, he's the first here

When they play well, or a player he hates does, he'e nowhere to be seen

Virtually everything he writes about United is negative.

When Chelsea beat Barca he was the forst on here going on about how their tactics were better than ours when in truth, the games were pretty identical with Barca just finishing better in our games. He couldn't resist comingon here having a pop at Sir Alex about the Wembley game despite it being a year ago

Don't be fooled mate

posted on 7/6/12

Oh don't get me wrong macca, I'm not sticking up for those views generally, I was just commenting on the topic in hand re him and Modric v cp and wes. Personally I found the latter more annoying.

More generally, as you know Im def very anti this constant slating of our players, especially knee jerk reactions like those against e.g. De Gea, or perhaps posters regularly showing little 'support' for the club or it's actions and seemigly complaining all the time, but that's a different discussion to this thread. Tbh I find hippo one of the more annoying posters in that respect anyway. I doubt that guy will be happy with united until messi lines up alongside, Ronaldo, Ozil and Rooney.

posted on 7/6/12

SLM is a Utd fan, misguided at times but is a Utd fan. His love of Modric and constant praise and defence of him whilst labeling our playerd cack after one game is what I find annoying about him.

On a separate note, anyone remember that Pokemon loving guy? His name was mark the mad or something

posted on 7/6/12

You actually think so MUDD? You argue with him every day

posted on 7/6/12

I'm trying to help the misguided young man Arab. One day I may get through to him

Page 3 of 4

Sign in if you want to comment