Please, no! Too injury prone and is not actually required.

I'd rather we didn't, there is much better on the market and I really can't be fussed with yet another "Boyhood heroes" speech....

Tell me about it... like I say I sincerley hope this is just WUM's but its all over Twatter (Twitter) and celticrumors etc

Past it? He's 28 forchristsakes. And has he not said in the past he has no interest in playing for either half of the old firm?

Karim ziani has been released on a free from wolfsburg. Anyone know anything about him? Reckon we have a chance?

Andy

Is he a goalie?

na he plays right or left. Played for algeria in the WC

All well and good, I suppose eil, Thommo and Big Johan might see him as a goalie though.......

IMO yes he is past it. He hit his peek 3 years ago and wont replicate the same form. Thats the way I feel. And the way he picks up knocks in training all the time he might as well have a seat on the bus with Davie Weird

So you say he's injury prone and make your point by comparing him to a player who has made more than 700 appearances in his career.

Even if he only plays 20 games he'd be better than anyone else in our league.

best player in the league!

Can faddy play upfront??

Andy, who's better? Hooper? Jelavic? Kayal? I don't think so.

Charlie, I think McFadden played upfront on his own against some mob in Paris a few years back. Can't remember who he got on.

Yep i'd say all 3 of those were better players. Naismith davis commons izaguirre all better players. If he was as good as you say surely he'd not have bombed down in england?

Yes- " a few years back". There is no point breaking a wage structure for a striker, the same applies to Bellamy.

Don't want him likes,He has turned down the chance to come to paradise twice already an now he wants to come because no one from the EPL will touch him,a would rather take a chance on Johan Carew.

I think McFadden played upfront on his own against some mob in Paris a few years back. Can't remember who he got on.
..........

Thats the thing with McFadden, one wonder goal and theres some that think he is consistent and unique.

Waste of a wage bill. Another Maloney, turned his back on Celtic to go to the Premiership once they hit a bit of form. Then when they fail miserably they expect us to give them a game.

You guys just live in your own little reality, don't you? In what way did McFadden "turn his back" on celtic? By not signing for them a few years ago? By that logic he also turned his back on Aberdeen. And Dundee Utd. And Valencia. And Rosenburg. And Boca Juniors. And every club in the world except Everton, presumably.

If you don't want him to sign out because you don't rate him or think he's injury-prone, fair enough. I have a different opinion, but you are entitled to yours.
But if you don't want him to sign out of spite for some perceived rejection is just childish.

And John Carew? You must be joking. Why not just sign Emile Heskey, or a tree? Same effect.

How very Aberdeen to think one flash in the pan years ago justifies an ongoing love...

Tin hat Hector! The 'don' will make you an offer I fear.

HMP

I'm open to offers, never say never...

Some sheepish comments on this board today.

Sadly, I accidentally filtered Hector to test the new wum filter and can't undo it for four weeks. If he says anything interesting, let me know.

Henrik, instead of making your undoubtedly hilarious remarks, why not try and respond to a point someone else has made? Y'know, like how adults have debates.

Did the don do a woolyback or Mrs. Mols?