Nani, by far...
We need to get him on a new contract asap! If we lose him and keep Young, I will be very upset!
They all over something different, but in terms of individual ability it's Nani
Nani is the most talented.
Nani for talent.
Nani and Valencia are pretty close in terms of effectiveness. With Valencia it is more reliant of power and speed, with Nani more on quick feet and trickiness. I'm glad we have both.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Nani, he is the most technically skilled and has been our top assist guy in most seasons. Valencia is close but Nani is a greater thret as he scores more than Valencia as well. Besides If you go outside of England Nani is actually ranked as our best player by most people.
With Lucas and Kagawa in the team I can see both Nani and Valencia reaching new heights as deffences will not afford to double up on them with the threat that is now in the center of the park.
Besides If you go outside of England Nani is actually ranked as our best player by most people.
-------------
It's a toss between him and Rooney for me.
Definitely Nani in terms of ability, but Valencia is just as effective. If Nani can improve his consistency then he should surpass Valencia though.
Nani one million per cent, followed by Valencia.
Those two should be first choice regardless of the opposition or who comes in imho
Can't believe you didn't start Valencia against us at the etihad
Nor me to be honest considering the form he was in from the turn of the year onwards
Cityblue, probably should have done as he was at his peak form for the season, however I can see why we chose the lineup we did on the wings as you would have said Nani would be more likely to cut open a defence, just wasn't his day
Can't believe you didn't start Valencia against us at the etihad
-------------
Sir Alex got it all wrong that day.
Starting with Giggs and Park, Scholes, Carrick & Nani in midfield.
Then, taking Park off for Wellbeck, leaving Giggs on the wing for another 20minutes, before bringing on Valencia.
How many times have we heard that just wasn't his day. Nani very overrated. Ferguson doesn't even think he Utds best right winger
Jack(U12011)
There is nothing to suggest SAF dosent think he is the best right winger. Nani is effective on both Wings and Valencia is effective on the right while young though good is not as good as Nani on the left nor valencia on the right making it a easier selection to have Valencia on the right and Nani on the left than having to put Nani on the right and Young on the left and leave valencia out
jack (U12011)
Is that why he plays him by and large on the left then?
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Who is our best winger?
Page 1 of 1
posted on 23/7/12
Nani, by far...
We need to get him on a new contract asap! If we lose him and keep Young, I will be very upset!
posted on 23/7/12
They all over something different, but in terms of individual ability it's Nani
posted on 23/7/12
Nani is the most talented.
posted on 23/7/12
Nani for talent.
Nani and Valencia are pretty close in terms of effectiveness. With Valencia it is more reliant of power and speed, with Nani more on quick feet and trickiness. I'm glad we have both.
posted on 23/7/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 23/7/12
Nani, he is the most technically skilled and has been our top assist guy in most seasons. Valencia is close but Nani is a greater thret as he scores more than Valencia as well. Besides If you go outside of England Nani is actually ranked as our best player by most people.
With Lucas and Kagawa in the team I can see both Nani and Valencia reaching new heights as deffences will not afford to double up on them with the threat that is now in the center of the park.
posted on 23/7/12
Besides If you go outside of England Nani is actually ranked as our best player by most people.
-------------
It's a toss between him and Rooney for me.
posted on 23/7/12
Definitely Nani in terms of ability, but Valencia is just as effective. If Nani can improve his consistency then he should surpass Valencia though.
posted on 23/7/12
Nani one million per cent, followed by Valencia.
Those two should be first choice regardless of the opposition or who comes in imho
posted on 23/7/12
Can't believe you didn't start Valencia against us at the etihad
posted on 23/7/12
Nor me to be honest considering the form he was in from the turn of the year onwards
posted on 23/7/12
Cityblue, probably should have done as he was at his peak form for the season, however I can see why we chose the lineup we did on the wings as you would have said Nani would be more likely to cut open a defence, just wasn't his day
posted on 23/7/12
Can't believe you didn't start Valencia against us at the etihad
-------------
Sir Alex got it all wrong that day.
Starting with Giggs and Park, Scholes, Carrick & Nani in midfield.
Then, taking Park off for Wellbeck, leaving Giggs on the wing for another 20minutes, before bringing on Valencia.
posted on 23/7/12
How many times have we heard that just wasn't his day. Nani very overrated. Ferguson doesn't even think he Utds best right winger
posted on 23/7/12
Jack(U12011)
There is nothing to suggest SAF dosent think he is the best right winger. Nani is effective on both Wings and Valencia is effective on the right while young though good is not as good as Nani on the left nor valencia on the right making it a easier selection to have Valencia on the right and Nani on the left than having to put Nani on the right and Young on the left and leave valencia out
posted on 23/7/12
jack (U12011)
Is that why he plays him by and large on the left then?
Page 1 of 1