So was David Silva

So was Diego Forlan.

So was Juan Mata

So am I.

So is any player coming into the PL

Jesus Christ you can't pally that logic to just Kagawa to suit your pathetic argument.

Kagawa has as much chance of being success as any player coming in.

Also German league is probably most similar to PL than any other league.

Pally - logic

iPhone's hey

Sorry if sound kranky I've been to funeral today, very sad day.

Whoa boys I think we are going off tangent – there is no way to know for sure if a player will or will not adapt to the premiership or the pressure of playing for a particular club – the younger the player is the more of a risk (that’s why I am slightly concerned about the Lucas deal considering the figures being quoted). For Kagawa the signs are promising
1) He has looked bright in the time we have seen him play on tour
2) He is 23 and has international and club experience at European level
3) He has played well, scored goals and assists during his time in the German league which is of a very high quality particularly in recent years

Back to the original post – it does feel similar to the summer of 07 when we signed Anderson, Tevez, Hargreaves and Nani BUT remember at that time we already had Ronaldo and Rooney. Is too early to see what this current side is capable of as I still think we are in a bit of a transition period – once Scholes, Giggs and Rio have left we will have a better idea

Like I said above apologies it's been a hard day for me.

VCD – sorry to hear that mate
Hope your alright

Yeah thanks appreciate it.

One of them things everyone has to go through, in some ways it's nice that it's over now.

chin up VCD

A team of:

De Gea
Vidic
Carrick
Valencia Anderson Kagawa Nani
Lucas RVP Rooney Welbeck

would win the treble hands down

Thanks red

Hope you're ok VCD

Yeah I'm ok, sorry I'm not trying to bum anyone out.

Was just apologising for being kranky.

Vidic – I’d love to see SAF put that team out purely to watch Vidic defend a corner on his own whilst 9 red shirts stand on the half way line waiting for the counter attack!

it's my fifa formation

VCD

I don't think people realise how well Kagawa's done the last 2 years.

He's by no means a guaranteed success, but I wouldn't class him as an unproven player.

All I meant by "unproven" was that he has no previous Premier League experience.

No probs DD

Can't argue with that double d, fair enough

Yeah my faulty I jumped on a comment due to having bad day.

DD is totally right, but all players from outside PL are obviously unproven in PL.

Because I was one season out I'm suddenly a plastic?? I struggle to remember dates, so what? Before I moved to the states this year I hadn't missed a competetive home game since I was about 10

Clown