Tevez

if theyre both fit and firing on all cylinders, van persie is the better player, just

I think RVP is a better technical footballer, but Tevez is more productive and a better goalscorer.

I'd take RVP anyday, and I'd have said that even if city also signed him and kept Tevez.

Tevez anyday, class above as a player

RVP hasn't played a game yet, Tevez has left his mark already , I'd expect that fans emotions with past and present would be hard to suppress, so I'm plumping that Utd fans will go for RVP.








Me I don't give a Shiite

Tevez has also been a complete and bad mouthed the club and manager and former players.

RVP stayed quiet, said he wouldn't sign new contract. Didn't disrespect Arsenal AT ALL, and hasn't conducted the whole saga over twitter like some.

I know who I prefer.

trying to judge them purely on football ability, and as much as i hate tevez, hes a wonderful little player, but yh try to judge this one football ability only

Do you support Utd Very?

Yes

And I'm not that keen on how Tevez has conducted himself since leaving us for City, he's acted like a spoilt little brat.

Disagree Very, he has disrespected Arsenal and Wenger big time. 8 years he has been with them and 7 of them were mostly spent on the injury table yet Wenger and the club kept the faith with him and didn't just get rid and now he has one good season and wants to f off.

Well not wants to, he is

just wanted to mark you down in the Rvp camp.

This whole garbage about him spending most of the time on injury table is BS

He played:

41 games
38 games
31 games
23 games
44 games
19 games
33 games
48 games

Ok a couple of bad seasons with low appearances, but 355 games in his career isn't bad as people make out.

Really tough choice when only based on football terms.

I think Tevez edges it because of his work rate

If managers picked players purely on ability then the likes of J Barton would not be hot-footing it out of the Prem!