or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 18 comments are related to an article called:

Manchester Utd vs Manchester City

Page 1 of 1

posted on 17/7/11

hart
richards
vidic
kompany
evra
silva
yaya
young
de jong
park
anderson
valencia
rooney
balotelli
dzeko
owen.
It's more than XI though

posted on 17/7/11

De Gea
Rafael
Vidic
Kompany
Jones
Evra
Fabio
Nani
Yaya
Johnson
De Jong
Park
Anderson
Valencia
Tevez
Hernandez
Berbatov
Owen

United win 13-5.

posted on 17/7/11

It's more than XI though

--------------------------------------------

lol thats true.

posted on 17/7/11

Hart >> De Gea
Richards >> Rafael
Vidic >> Toure
Kompany >> Ferdinand
Lescott >> Jones
Evra >> Clichy + Kolorov
Fabio >> Bridge
Silva >> Nani (they're different players. Nani is a better winger, but Silva is the better overall player)
Y. Toure >> Carrick
Johnson >> Young
De Jong >> Fletcher
Barry = Park
Anderson >> Johnson
Valencia >> Milner
Rooney >> Tevez (really tough one)
Balotelli >>>>>>>>> Hernandez
Berba >> Dzeko
Ade >> Owen

posted on 17/7/11

No contest. Hands down it'll be City all day

posted on 17/7/11

De Gea
Richards
Vidic
Kompany
Lescott
Evra
Fabio
Nani
Y.Toure
Young
De Jong
Park
Anderson
Valencia
Tevez
Hernandez
Dzeko
Adebayor

Man City 8-10 Man Utd

posted on 17/7/11

Barry = Park

-----

No.

comment by nolhman (U1545)

posted on 17/7/11

Kamran have to disagree. Park is better than Barry and Nani is better than Silva. Stats don't lie.

posted on 17/7/11

Hart or De Gea - Draw
Rafael or Richards - Rafael
Vidic or Toure - Vidic
Ferdinand or Kompany - Draw now
Jones or Lescott - Lescott for now
Evra or Clichy/Kolorov - Evra
Fabio or Bridge - Fabio
Nani or Silva - Nani
Y.Toure or Carrick - Yaya
Adam Johnson or Young - Johnson just
De Jong or Fletcher - Fletcher just
Barry or Park Park
M.Johnson or Anderson - Anderson
Milner or Valencia - Valencia
Tevez or Rooney - Rooney
Hernandez or Balotelli - Hernandez
Dzeko or Berba - Berba
Adebayor or Owen - Owen

posted on 17/7/11

Hart or De Gea? De Gea unproven in Prem. Hart.
Rafael or Richards? Richards is a sicknote; Rafael
Vidic or Toure? Vidic. Kolo is a cheat
Ferdinand or Kompany? RioFerdy5
Jones or Lescott? unproven...maybe Lescott of 3seasons ago
Evra or Clichy/Kolorov? Evra
Fabio or Bridge? Bridge on career, fabio on potential
Nani or Silva? Silva...Nani flatters to deceive
Y.Toure or Carrick? Toure. How about me or Carrick..maybe closer
Adam Johnson or Young? Tie
De Jong or Fletcher? De Jong
Barry or Park? different kind of player but Park
M.Johnson or Anderson? Anderson
Milner or Valencia? Valencia
Tevez or Rooney? Tevez
Hernandez or Balotelli? Ballo on ability
Dzeko or Berba? equally overrated
Adebayor or Owen? Ade

posted on 17/7/11

Hart or De Gea? De Gea unproven in Prem. Hart.
Rafael or Richards? Richards is a sicknote; Rafael
Vidic or Toure? Vidic. Kolo is a cheat
Ferdinand or Kompany? RioFerdy5
Jones or Lescott? unproven...maybe Lescott of 3seasons ago
Evra or Clichy/Kolorov? Evra
Fabio or Bridge? Bridge on career, fabio on potential
Nani or Silva? Silva...Nani flatters to deceive
Y.Toure or Carrick? Toure. How about me or Carrick..maybe closer
Adam Johnson or Young? Tie
De Jong or Fletcher? De Jong
Barry or Park? different kind of player but Park
M.Johnson or Anderson? Anderson
Milner or Valencia? Valencia
Tevez or Rooney? Tevez
Hernandez or Balotelli? Ballo on ability
Dzeko or Berba? equally overrated
Adebayor or Owen? Ade

---------------------------------------------------

Agree on of all of yours <ok>

comment by nolhman (U1545)

posted on 17/7/11

Not going to have this debate. However, there is nothing deceiving about 18 assists and 9 goals in the league. Something Nani got last season. Easily the best winger in the league.

posted on 17/7/11

No I want Liverpool Vs MUFC!

posted on 17/7/11

Dzeko or Berba? equally overrated

--------------------------------------------------------------

Someone is still bitter about Berbatov's hat-trick against Liverpool last season, and being top scorer in the League even though he didn't feature much at the end of the season.

Nani, what nolhman said!

posted on 17/7/11

Fine I'll do a MUFC V's Liverpool Article myself!

Totally unbiased of course

posted on 17/7/11

Hart or De Gea? Hart
Rafael or Richards? Richards
Vidic or Toure? Vidic
Ferdinand or Kompany? Kompany
Jones or Lescott? Lescott
Evra or Clichy/Kolorov? Clichy
Fabio or Bridge? Fabio
Nani or Silva? Silva
Y.Toure or Carrick? Yaya
Adam Johnson or Young? AJ
De Jong or Fletcher? NDJ
Barry or Park? Park
M.Johnson or Anderson? Anderson(only because MJ will be drunk)
Milner or Valencia? TIE!
Tevez or Rooney? TIE!
Hernandez or Balotelli? Balo
Dzeko or Berba? Dzeko
Adebayor or Owen? Adebadbuy


posted on 21/7/11

Evra or Clichy/Kolorov? Clichy
Hernandez or Balotelli? Balo
Dzeko or Berba? Dzeko
----------------------------------

Lets break that down a bit then, Evra, the established French left back is not as good as the backup French left back, Clichy? Why would France purposely pick a worse player as their first choice??

Then you have Hernandez, who is undisputedly the bargain of last season, who scored 20 goals in all competitions, follows that up with a hatfull of international goals in the close season, and you think Balotelli, who can't even put a training top on is better than him?!

Then you compare Edin "couldn't-hit-a-barn-door" Dzeko against the top scorer in the country and think he is better.....

The only City players i would have in my team are Kompany (quality last season), Yaya Toure and Silva - the rest are expensive second-rate players.

posted on 21/7/11

Mouseburger (U8572)
Lets take your point one at a time shall we..
Evra or Clichy? I choose Clichy why? at club level Evra has Vidic and Ferdinand to cover his mistakes where as Clichy had the Arsenal centre backs... Clichy is (a) younger (b) faster (c) bigger (d) proberly has more assists

Little Poo or Balotelli? Balotelli every day of the week could Little Poo do this? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pFi_yoTp5c
Little Poo has decent movement and gets in good poistions where as Balotelli(as daft as he is) is capable of winning games on his own!

Dzeko or Berbatov? Dzeko... I will ask you at the end of the season what you think.


Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment