or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 119 comments are related to an article called:

Is Per...

Page 1 of 5

posted on 7/10/12

Comment deleted by Article Creator

posted on 7/10/12

Comments that are just a smiley will not be tolerated

posted on 7/10/12

Ok.

That's hilarious

Does that count?

posted on 7/10/12

I remember last season, most of my mates we're trying to work out how he'd won 80 caps for Germany. I don't think they thought of the possibility that he might me a top-class defender. And now he's proving it, justifying my faith.

It's just a shame there are still a few idiots who play too much FIFA and claim he's crap because he's slow. In fact he's actually decent on FIFA, and excellent in real life.

posted on 7/10/12

Fred, you feel we have more world class players?
If you think Per is a bad CB you have bad judgement.

posted on 7/10/12

Liverpool would love a defender who has as much quality as Per. And don't throw Agger my way, good defender but not on our BFG's level.

posted on 7/10/12

He definately isnt world class, but i remember when we signed him, my grandad who lived in germany said to me, that player you just signed is one of the best defenders in the world.

posted on 7/10/12

that player you just signed is one of the best defenders in the world.
===========
So he is world class.

Or are you saying your grandad is an idiot?

Don't disrespect your elders.

posted on 7/10/12

Agger is better than Per not that that's anything to do with the article.

Cazorla is your world class player.

Per is just a good defender, there are many many better than him in the league.

Agger, Vidic, Terry, Luiz, Cahill, Skrtel, Koscielney, Kompany, Lescott. Hell even Collocini probably.

posted on 7/10/12

posted on 7/10/12

No he is not. Agger plays for relegation fodder.

posted on 7/10/12

Agger, Vidic, Terry, Luiz, Cahill, Skrtel, Koscielney, Kompany, Lescott. Hell even Collocini probably.
=========
No, career over, no, , no, no, no, yes, no, no.

posted on 7/10/12

Per is better than Kompany now I see

If you guys had lost yesterday he'd be the worst player to have pulled on one of your crappy plastic shirts

Ickle gooners.

posted on 7/10/12

Per is better than Kompany now I see
=======
Idiot.

posted on 7/10/12

Arsenal fans have been singing his praises for a while now, and just like Koscielny he's finally starting to be appreciated by others.

Shouldn't you be discussing with Wigan or Reading fans?

posted on 7/10/12

Agger, Vidic, Terry, Luiz, Cahill, Skrtel, Koscielney, Kompany, Lescott. Hell even Collocini probably.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

OK, lets do this 1 by 1.

Agger I'll give you. He's fantastic.

Vidic hasn't really played for year so you can't judge him. He makes a lot of mistakes too.

Terry was great. But if you don't rate Merte for a lack of pace, Terry is rapidly losing what little speed he had.

Luiz is a joke of a defender. Has all the tools but a terrible mentality, awful positioning, rash etc.

Cahill is decent, nothing more.

Skrtel is good but not fantastic, he's a bit overrated IMO. Lacks composure on the ball, some people only rate him highly because he looks like a murderer.

Koscielny is very good of course, I trust Per more than him though.

Kompany I'll give you.

Lescott is so limited and make mistakes, no chance.

Coloccini has had 1 good season. Per has been quality for years.

Any more?

posted on 7/10/12

Per is a good centre back but he is not world class and he is not even your best cetre back.

posted on 7/10/12

He is, and he is.

posted on 7/10/12

Not the best CB in the world, but a world class CB none the less

The OP is obviously drunk still.... Not the best CB, but still world class

posted on 7/10/12

Verty is twice the player

posted on 7/10/12

So only the best player in a certain position is world class?

Iker Casillas is arguably the best keeper in the world so he is the only world class keeper?

posted on 7/10/12

Vertonghen is a LB, and not very good defensively.

Only seen him once for Spurs, tbh, but he was very poor defensively and should have been punished more than once.

posted on 7/10/12

Not the best CB in the world, but a world class CB none the less

The OP is obviously drunk still.... Not the best CB, but still world class
-------
Nothing wrong with the OP's statement.

posted on 7/10/12

I hate this World Class tag that is bounded around - everyone seems to have different definitions of what it means. Per is a top centre back though, the calming presence he brings to our back line is invaluable.

posted on 7/10/12

A world class player is usually someone who would get into a world 11 squad.

Frankly our last truly world class player was Cesc. Maybe RVP for a year.

Page 1 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment