or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 17 comments are related to an article called:

Ratings.

Page 1 of 1

posted on 10/11/12

everyone 0 apart from 2 7.5's for theo and giroud.

posted on 10/11/12

Vermaelen ? Are you taking the micky

posted on 10/11/12

Vito 5
Vermaelen 3
Koscielny 6.5
Mertesacker 6
Sagna 5.5
Coquelin 6
Arteta 2
Cazorla 5.5
Podolski 5.5
Walcott 7
Giroud 8.5

Subs
Ramsey 5.5
Ox 5.5
Arshavin 5.5

posted on 10/11/12

No offence OP but I'm so fed up of seeing ratings articles. What's the point.

posted on 10/11/12

Fair ratings, thought Ramsey was awful, should have got 2 yellow's and generally poor.

posted on 10/11/12

Forgot to change subs, should be

Ramsey 1.5
Ox 3
Arshavin 5

posted on 10/11/12

No offence OP but I'm so fed up of seeing ratings articles. What's the point.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

To discuss the players, essentially the point of the forum. If you don't like them, don't read them?

posted on 10/11/12

To discuss the players, essentially the point of the forum. If you don't like them, don't read them?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Win as a team, lose as a team. Most players performed a bit better. Vermaelen Manonne Arteta

posted on 10/11/12

Cheers Chris. You can't buy class - its not like the title didn't warn you.

Sick of Ramsey and vermaelen bashing by the way. I don't think they were any worse than the rest of the team.

posted on 10/11/12

Vermaelen wasn't that bad I don't think. Cazorla definitely wasn't 7 either, Theo perhaps deserves a 7.

Mannone: 4, awful display
Vermaelen: 5.5, at fault for the 2nd goal
Merte: 6, could perhaps have done better for 1st goal.
Koscielny: 5.5 poor 1st half, OK 2nd
Sagna: 5.5 average defensively and poor going forward

Arteta: 4 bad mistake for their penalty and crumbled under the pressure.
Coquelin: 5.5 offered little
Cazorla: 6 again quiet, did produce a couple of moments but needs to improve, not like there wasn't much space either.

Poldi: 6.5, well taken goal and fairly neat but needs to work harder. Might have scored again if Walcott had found him instead of shooting.

Theo: 7 worked hard and produced two good crosses but a couple of occasions where his vision let him down.

Giroud: 8 excellent display, well taken goals and full of desire and character, unlike most of the team.

posted on 10/11/12

Mannone - 4

Sagna - 5
Merte - 5.5
Kos - 5.5
Verm - 4.5

Arteta - 4
Coquelin - 4.5
Cazorla - 5

Theo - 7
OG - 8
Pod - 5.5

Subs:

Ramsey - 4
OX - 4.5
Arshavin - 5.5

posted on 10/11/12

Santos; -1

posted on 10/11/12

Mannone - 3

Sagna - 5
Merte - 5.5
Kos - 5.5
Verm - 4.5

Arteta - 4
Coquelin - 5,5
Cazorla - 5

Theo - 7
OG - 8
Pod - 5

Subs:

Ramsey - 2
OX - 4.5
Arshavin - you cant rate a player for playing 5 min.

posted on 10/11/12

Gunnerthru how was ramsey our worst player?! He gave away the ball once badly just after coming on, but otherwise he was fine!!

As I said, fed up of people just saying he's awful when he's doing no worse than the rest of the team.

posted on 10/11/12

Undercover, he slows down our midfield game when we need pace as usual. He gave the ball away to often. His passing game my god why do I need to discuss it. Non existent. He did it all 20 min. I think it deserve to be one of our worst player.

posted on 10/11/12

Agree with gunnerthru tbh.

posted on 10/11/12

Kamran

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment