Chicharito???

Why did Young get a 3?

Chicharito?!!!

Also, Valencia 5? He mustve made about 10 crosses today, not one lead to a chance. Rafael put in a couple and got an assist.

I tihnk 5s about right, but looking at the rest of your ratings, he should be a 4

Thought was quite ineffective for most of the game. At least Rooney was getting the ball and trying

I'm talking about rvp

De Gea 6

Rafael 7
Smalling 6
Ferdinand 6
Evra 6

Valencia 3
Carrick 5
Scholes 6
Young 3

Rooney 6
RVP 7

Cleverley 8
Anderson 7
Chicharito 9

I'm quite a harsh rater so here's mine:

De Gea - 7
Rafael - 6
Evra - 6
Ferdinand - 7
Smalling - 6 [Coming back from injury so he's not going to be up to speed]

Valencia - 4 [He needs to look up before crossing]
Carrick - 5
Young - 5
Scholes - 6
Anderson - 5 [Didn't do anything special despite hoping he'd change the game]
Cleverley - 6

Rooney - 6
Van Persie - 8
Hernandez - 10

De Gea 7 - Did well on crosses got rid of them did everything asked of him

Rafa - 6
Rio - 6
Smalling - 6 (he had a great end to the game made some crucial challenges and headers)
Evra - 6

Valencia - 5 (Ended the game well but he was doubled up on and struggled)
Carrick - 5 (Poor passing, made some great tackles at the end of the game)
Scholes - 6 (Great assist)
Young - 6 (Unfair to give him 5 we never have him the ball)

Rooney - 5 (Poor game, poor touch, pass passing most of the game)
RVP - 7 (should have scored header but last 20 minutes was very good)

Hernandez - 9 ( was organising the forward line, was all over the pitch like a fly and for the winner he was setting up the play which gave him space)

Anderson - 6
Cleverly -7

young a 3?

Young was pretty atrocious, as he has been in most games he has played this season. Our 3 main wingers have all been horribly out of form this season, it's pretty worrying.