- home advantage - 4 slots
- tactics strength - 4 slots
- team strength - 4 slots
- impact of subs - 4 slots
- form - 4 slots

that could be fair

would it not be fairer to put a bit more bias on tactics as that is waht we all spend time putting effort into?

Say:

- home advantage - 3 slots
- tactics strength - 6 slots
- team strength - 5 slots
- impact of subs - 3 slots
- form - 3 slots

i was going to suggest that.

perhaps see loyals thoughts but that does seem the fairer way

Wilshire

- home advantage - 3 slots
- tactics strength - 6 slots
- team strength - 5 slots
- impact of subs - 3 slots
- form - 3 slots

Maybe 2 for home advantage? Then an extra for subs or team strenght?

i think if we lower it to 2 for home advantage it should go to subs. tactics should out weigh the others

- home advantage - 2 slots
- tactics strength - 6 slots
- team strength - 5 slots
- impact of subs - 4 slots
- form - 3 slots

Looks better I think

so to explain it through that CEF

if i did Norwich vs Sunderland and it was like this -

home advantage - Norwich
- tactics strength - Sunderland
- team strength - Draw
- impact of subs - Norwich
- form - Sunderland

i would set it up like this on the generator

1. Norwich
2. Norwich
3. Sunderland
4. Sunderland
5. Sunderland
6. Sunderland
7. Sunderland
8. Sunderland
9. Draw
10. Draw
11. Draw
12. Draw
13. Draw
14. Norwich
15. Norwich
16. Norwich
17. Norwich
18. Sunderland
19. Sunderland
20. Sunderland

so because sunderland are stronger tactics wise and form wise they have the most chance of winning. however its close so a draw/norwich win can happen

Loyal/Wilshire

Sounds spot on to me. Nice and clear. Pop that in the rules and you really shouldn't get too many disagreements

Just one more suggestion from me:

Maybe you should do 'a best of 3' when you draw. It will give a more realistic result i my opinion. If you happen to draw 3 different results, either draw a 4th time or make the result a draw. What do you think???

League looks great

CEF glad you have found a tleague which i can honestly say will be brilliant IMO

good win for bolton against us BTW in the fa cup...as i said on boltons match thread good luck against everton and good luck for the rest of the season

Maybe you should do 'a best of 3' when you draw. It will give a more realistic result i my opinion. If you happen to draw 3 different results, either draw a 4th time or make the result a draw. What do you think???

Its always best of 3 mate

yeah sorry should have mentioned it was best of 3

Cheers Wigan. Very pleasing (and unexpected) win. Fancy we might manage to do something against Everton

Loyal/Wilshire - great minds think alike

our players just never turned up first time i have seen MON angry tbh.... we missed JOS and Fletcher too but you just wanted it more

What are the chances of Fletcher playing this weekend Wigan?? Got him on Fantasy Football a couple of days ago and now he's got an 'Illness' apparently...

its your dreaded game today wigan

wigan vs sunderland

who will you be supporting?

no idea Ji

its not dreded at all Wigan today after sunderland won earlier in the season... .though if sunderland win its also good.... but if its a draw i will be annoyed

however if reading scor eary i will be watching that want newcaste to go into the relegation zone

hope fletch is back but im not confident he is

Wigan do you want to join this league. Doesnt have to be permanently it can be temporarily until a new member is interested. Im just thinking that maybe if the league gets going people might be more interested

also loyal if 1 team doesn't win on any of those slots i think maybe we should take 1 off form and give them that 1 cause they still took their time to do tactics.

also everyone fine with using head to head records instead of goal difference when deciding a league position

^ Agree with that, even the crappiest team has to have a chance. Even if it's just 1/20...

And yeah head to head sounds fine by me.

Hey guys .

How about getting this final person in then? How we getting on with it?

i was thinking we should get a temp manager in so we can get the league going

then maybe when it actually starts more people will be interested

I'll take the trouble off your hands Wilsh and give it a bash