or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 34 comments are related to an article called:

Vote: If You Could..

Page 1 of 2

posted on 24/1/13

I'm sure most of you know who I'd like to be brought back

I reckon he'd do a good job with this squad, and would we'd be able to see more of an organised plan long term with the club if he came back.

posted on 24/1/13

2

posted on 24/1/13

Can't see past Jose, sorry! I know that's not the aim of the article.

posted on 24/1/13

I'm sure most of you know who I'd like to be brought back

I reckon he'd do a good job with this squad, and would we'd be able to see more of an organised plan long term with the club if he came back.

----------

Agree, Grant would be great

comment by TGI (U9236)

posted on 24/1/13

BK, there's no way Grant's coming back so just forget it.

posted on 24/1/13

Carlo or RDM.

On the balance I had to choose Carlo as he really could have built a fantastic team had been given more time. Some of the football we played 09/10 was just incredible.

posted on 24/1/13

'this summer'*
Nice one is that cause there's not enough stars on here !

posted on 24/1/13

AVB Blue? He would suit ya'll perfectly now. But I guess you wouldn't have a Champions league trophy. Romans daft logic wins.

posted on 24/1/13

haha yeah, let's vote for AVBanter

posted on 24/1/13

1L, TGI

With Carlo I'm still not convinced he can handle a transition, and he can suffer from tactical rigidness espiecally if you remember his second season.. He's doing alright at PSG though but he is still underachieving considering the squad he has and his competition, while AVB is doing just about what he needs to do.

With RDM, he would probably be my second choice. I wasn't as big a fan of him as others during his interim reign, but looking back you can see he used the squad in the best way possible for a short-term use. This season he changed it, and I was confident we had a strong manager who could take us forward, not amazing but definitely good.

posted on 24/1/13

Carlo is a terrible manager.

How can you be failing with that PSG squad?! Only an idiotic thick eyebrowed Italian manager. Thats whats gong on.

posted on 24/1/13

I'd love for Di Matteo to come back for a day just so we could thank him and give him a big and for bringing big ears to the Bridge.

posted on 24/1/13

Rdm

Only if he completely abandons the mikel/lampard combo,

posted on 24/1/13

Carlo for me.

posted on 24/1/13

Carlo, it's the logical choice.

posted on 24/1/13

Carlo is no logical choice.

He's a weak league manager.

How can you not win the french league title with the amount money spent and the players at your disposal? Just ridiculous. To make matters worse, PSG were top of the table when they got rid of the previous manager. To make matters even worse, he lost the title to Montpellier

This season he isnt doing much better even though they have even better players.

posted on 24/1/13

I'd go for Carlo out of those choices.

posted on 24/1/13

Wow at Carlo failing at a league which is marginally better than a league where AVB absolutely bossed.

posted on 24/1/13

Grant

comment by TGI (U9236)

posted on 24/1/13

PSG have crap players, other than a few decent attackers.

posted on 24/1/13

I could make a case for Carlo being our greatest manager EVER.

comment by JNR :] (U10993)

posted on 24/1/13

Out of those only AVB has the ability to lead this squad to greatness.

posted on 24/1/13

You seemed to have missed Scolari from the list but nonetheless it has to be Carlo for me

posted on 24/1/13

Whoops you're right

Too many managers

posted on 24/1/13

Definitely Carlo

Bar Mourinho the best manager we've had, end of.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment