or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 93 comments are related to an article called:

Which would you pick?

Page 3 of 4

comment by Szoboss (U6997)

posted on 26/1/13

GB, I love you man but you gotta lay off the pipe!

posted on 26/1/13

I would pick F...

Carlton Cole, Andy Carroll, Marouane Chamakh, Modibo Maiga and Kevin Nolan

posted on 26/1/13

Look at Gerarrd and Suarez stats for the season
-
gerrard - 5 goals 8 assists (in league) = 13
cazolra - 8 goals 6 assists (in league) = 14

Suarez - 16 g, 3 a = 19
walcott - 10g, 7a = 17

difference? suarez has started 10 more games than walcott.

dont bring up stats GB if they are absolute blocks.

posted on 26/1/13

I would take one from each.

Plus why no Baines

posted on 26/1/13

Could've easily included Newcastle in this but would've had to include every team in between

posted on 26/1/13

I was only using mids and forwards

posted on 26/1/13

so you're saying walcott is better than suarez!

posted on 26/1/13

Why did you put Podolski in then

posted on 26/1/13

so you're saying walcott is better than suarez!
-
im not saying he is GB brought up stats, i provided stats that suggested against his point. dont jump to assumptions.

posted on 26/1/13

why would i just if im on my laptop

posted on 26/1/13

jump

posted on 26/1/13

????

posted on 26/1/13

Ramsey? What??

Goals

Suarez has 16 goals
Walcott has 10

Suarez wins.

------------------------------

Assists

Gerard has 8 assists
Carzola has 6 Assists


Gerrard wins.

i dont get your point.......our striker scored more than your striker; our midfielder creates more than your midfielder........whats YOUR point?? Stats BACK ME UP....NOT YOU

posted on 26/1/13

i dont get your point.......our striker scored more than your striker; our midfielder creates more than your midfielder........whats YOUR point?? Stats BACK ME UP....NOT YOU
-
i was adding goals and assists up, you know, because a assist creates a goal, and a goal is a goal, so both result in goals create/finished by that player.

so stats dont back you up.

posted on 26/1/13

No ramsey...no, nice try tho. Top striker at the end of the season doesnt say he scored x amount and x assists.....its goals scored,for example:

Assume,

Walcott scored 15 and had 13 assists
Suarez scored 25 and had 5 assists

Suarez would be top scorer.....thats how its works. You cant add assist to a scorers record!!!! viva versa u cant add goals to an assists.

LFC have players who have scored and made more assists than Arsenals.....simple, that why i chose LFC players NOT arsenals!!!

posted on 26/1/13

Walcott scored 15 and had 13 assists
Suarez scored 25 and had 5 assists
-
this would mean walcott has contributed more goals to the team, than suarez.

what, so you dont want your strikers to assist? would you complain if suarez ever actually passed the ball? you would rather he took one of his 12.5 shots that it takes him to score?


with gerrard, would you rather he passed to a teammate than scored a open goal because he is a midfielder, he shouldnt be scoring, he should be assisting? you bell.

a football player is a football player, the more goals you contribute to a team the better. strikers arent restricted to goals, midfielders arent restricted to assists.

posted on 26/1/13

Lol Rev, wtf are you doing getting into a serious debate with that oaf?

posted on 26/1/13

hello kam, how are you?

posted on 26/1/13

I'm doing very well thank you sir.

You?

posted on 26/1/13

I dont care if Suarez takes 3000 shots to hit the target once, aslong as he knocks in 20-30 goals a season; take a look at the top goalscorers....it seems hes doing alrght,dont it??


And your missing the point,,,which is when talking stats; its just that goal stats OR assist stats......thats how the prem league awar the golden boot...its not an addition of both is it??

posted on 26/1/13

Ramsey I'd have more sympathy with you if you weren't exaggerating the Suarez goals to shots statistic.

From Sky Sports: Shots on target 51, shots off target 97, goals 20

148/20 = 7.4

comment by RKW (U13169)

posted on 26/1/13

4. Suarez, Sturridge, Coutinho, Sterling, Gerrard

Try to be unbiased
---
Oh...

posted on 26/1/13

The best stat Got_Beaten overlooked. All the players listed for other clubs......are in a higher league position than the Liverpool players listed.

Stats, lies and statistics

posted on 26/1/13

Oaf??? its the 17th century everyone

posted on 26/1/13

we arent talking about who is going to win the golden boot though are we? we are talking about who contributes more to their team. goals & assists.


not bad kam. each and every day though, i meet more and more deluded souls on this site, too many for me to fix alone.

Page 3 of 4

Sign in if you want to comment