or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 44 comments are related to an article called:

Is this really fair?

Page 1 of 2

posted on 23/2/13

so why didn't your club do it then if its allowed?

posted on 23/2/13

^^^^^^ yep that solves the problem pep?!?!?!

You are right, it is wrong, no doubt about it really and im pretty sure you will see a rule change because of it in the very near future.

posted on 23/2/13

It aint right Wofie, it just aint right.

Pants club too, pants ground, pants fans, pants pants pants

posted on 23/2/13

Pep's, your club did it because your owners also own Udinese and Granada. Our owner is a builder.

posted on 23/2/13

If every club did it pep's, then when or how could young players from the UK develop. You only started with one home grown player.

posted on 23/2/13

don't see the problem

posted on 23/2/13

Don't see a problem with it. Watford are within the rules and are deservedly heading for promotion.

posted on 23/2/13

lol, not sure how anyone cant see a problem with it and then in the same breath complain about the lack of british talent making it through at club and international level.

I remember rules from a previous time which tried to block owners from having a stake in more than one club, not sure what happened to them?

comment by TaraTV (U16260)

posted on 23/2/13

Like people have said Watford are doing nothing wrong and it looks like there maybe a change in the rule come the summer

http://www1.skysports.com/football/news/11699/8509824

posted on 23/2/13

The fact the rule is going to change tells you all you need to know.
They are doing nowt wrong regarding the rules right now, but it is a farce to allow it to happen

posted on 23/2/13

Its plain and simple. I believe they have bent the rule book as far as they can, they have cheated and wont be able to do it next season. Just not cricket.

posted on 23/2/13

definitely trace.

posted on 23/2/13

As long as there are loopholes there will be someone to take advantage, whether it is Apple, Starbucks, Vodafone, Bridgemere etc legally screwìng the UK through tax avoidance - or Watford FC seeing a gap in the loan rules.

Man City's owners have found a handy workaround concerning the fair play rules which soon come into effect - and planned for it some time back.

The first thing any businessman will look at when looking at rules and laws is how to exploit potential loopholes.

posted on 23/2/13

Chicken Biryani on the way

posted on 23/2/13

Firstly, they haven't been promoted yet.

Also bear in mind how difficult it would be for them if they were to get promoted - losing many of their loan signings - having to play a new team that haven't played much together.

posted on 23/2/13

I don't think the owner will care much - no immediate plans for anything but a massive profit, given their way of attempting promotion in the first place.

posted on 23/2/13

No one is disputing the loopholes unc....the point is the moral standpoint of the situation.

posted on 23/2/13

Business and morals rarely mix.

posted on 23/2/13

Are loans fair full stop ?

All teams have squad and youth team players to cover injuries etc.

posted on 23/2/13

I think loans are no real use to any club unless there is a stipulation allowing for a signing afterwards.
it undermines the youth set up at any club.

comment by MrTikka (U8329)

posted on 23/2/13

Fair play to them, bringing in so many loan players doesn't automatically equate do doing as well as this Watford side are atm - probably nobody would have batted an eyelid if they were in the bottom half.

Watford have been one of the bright spots in what's been a pretty poor division imo, you have to hand it to Zola if he does win promotion this season, love to know what price they were at the start for auto - good luck to them hope they make it

posted on 23/2/13

What about half time oranges? Do they give an advantage?

What about transfers?

How about teams can only field a player if they were born in the same city?

posted on 23/2/13

Silly boy

posted on 23/2/13

Top performance may depend on the juiciness of the orange and the amount of solids in the juice (at least 10% solids are required for the AA grade).

If Cardiff were to buy a Florida orange and Wolves were tucking into a Navel orange, the Cardiff players would be assisted by a higher proportion of anhydric citric acid in fruit solids which could enhance their second half performance.

posted on 23/2/13

Doesn't feel right to me, within the laws yes, but right no

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment