or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 110 comments are related to an article called:

Newcastle - FA Premier League

Page 4 of 5

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 18/3/13

well I like Alaba as a player - but as he is below Enrique in your team he can't be rated well so I don't think we can come to a deal as unless you will improve my 1st team i wouldn't let him go

feel free to offer for him though
----------
Enrique has been awesome and of one the best LB in the PL IMO.

I rate him as he is as good offensively as defensively.
I rate him as equal as Alaba so dont really matter which one I pick.

Alba + Marchisio + Kroos +
for
Alaba/Enrique + Cambiasso + Ozil + Shaqiri

Alba>Alaba/Enrique
Marchisio>Cambiasso
Kroos<Ozil
<<Shaqiri who can play anywhere in that midfield

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 18/3/13

Alba > Alaba
Cahill < Subotic
Cavani => Villa
Moutinho <= Sandro

----
screw it ... I can deal on that.
We have been going back and forwards and think it's about time we deal.

Confirm on my page please?

posted on 18/3/13

alba+x = clichy+x

posted on 18/3/13

Cahill + Henrikh + Piazon + Hernandez
= Bonucci + Hamsik + Mandzukic
Enq

to be honest i dont see any gain at all for me there

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 18/3/13

Just asking how a few are rated on here but we must be close feel your gainin more atm but i cba to negotiate any more
----------------------
I really think it is a fair deal.

Confirm?

posted on 18/3/13

Agger + Lloris + Hernandez + Ramsey + Morata
=
Dante + Neuer + Mandzukic + Bender
Enq
----------
the same again really, agger is one of my favourite players, but he still not rated any higher than dante and none of the others are a gain

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 18/3/13

Can we add Dzageov for Shaqiri
And its a deal
You lose in your back up but think you gain slightly more in 1st team
----------------------

You seem to dabble it again.
Shaqiri is a good squad player for me.

If we do that then change Moutinho for Marchisio

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 18/3/13

Can we add Dzageov for Shaqiri
And its a deal
You lose in your back up but think you gain slightly more in 1st team
-----------------------
go on then....lets do it.

I need to go after other targets.

Confirm on my page

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 18/3/13

??

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 18/3/13

Alba + Moutinho + Cavani + Cahill + Dzageov
=
Alaba + Sandro + Villa + Subotic + Shaqiri
---------
deal.

comment by Park (U13708)

posted on 19/3/13

Gomez + Javi Garcia
=
Hernandez + Marchisio??

comment by Park (U13708)

posted on 19/3/13

Erm... Could add Gustavo in, but i'd want Gundogan in the deal. Something like...

Gomez + Garcia + Gustavo
=
Hernandez + Marchisio + Gundogan??

comment by Guv (U12850)

posted on 19/3/13

Rooney + Howedes + Parker
For
Villa + Agger + Marchisio

Enq

comment by Guv (U12850)

posted on 19/3/13

Howedes > Agger for sure.
Rooney better than Villa now.
Parker/Sandro combo.

No worries.

posted on 19/3/13

Pepe + Arbeloa + Fellaini + Nani
=
Subotic + Boateng + Marchisio + Lavezzi
enq

Pepe > Subo
Arbeloa > Boateng
Fellaini < Marchisio
Nani < Lavezzi

posted on 19/3/13

There's always a deal to be done, maybe not the one that was previously on the table, but there's something!

posted on 20/3/13

rio+clichy+llorente = agger+alaba+villa

improves your side in rio and clichy

posted on 20/3/13

Hernandez ?

posted on 20/3/13

Abate + Fellaini
=
Marchisio

posted on 20/3/13

Lol don't be ridiculous. Raf is one of the best RB's around. Abate isn't bad, fastest RB around. And don't think the difference between fellaini n matchisio is anywhere near what you think. Nvm.

posted on 21/3/13

Nani/kagawa > nasri
March < fellaini
Abate >

No thanks. Wouldn't want nasri back in any way, shape or form.

posted on 23/3/13

Interested in Marchisio, Kroos and Lavezzi.

comment by Park (U13708)

posted on 24/3/13

Badstuber + Rodriguez + Menez + Cech + Javi Garcia
=
Agger + Nasri + Marchisio + Hernandez?

posted on 25/3/13

March = Martinez
Ribery => Lavezzi
Ekotto => Abate (for as Adriano is Right Footed (RWB at Sevilla- and out injuired so rep will lower - while Ekotto is on fire at spurs)
Nasri > Tello - can leave this out if you prefer
-----------
I would say Martinez is comfortably better than Marchisio, especially as a DM rather than a CM.

Not bothered about Abate, can include him in any deal as he's my back up. (Not sure what you're on about Sevilla... Adriano is at Barca) Not sure how you can say Ekotto is on fire when he has only played 5 matches and they have lost 3 and drawn 1 of them.

Ribery is comfortably better than Lavezzi, to even allude to him being nearly = is ridiculous.

Again, Tello is back up for me so can be included in anything.
------------------
Marchisio
=
Fellaini + Tello

Gets you a winger who is better than Nasri and a solid replacement in CM.

comment by Park (U13708)

posted on 25/3/13

Badstuber + Rodriguez + Menez + Cech + Javi Garcia
=
Agger + Nasri + Marchisio + Hernandez?

How about I add in Gomez and you put in Lamela? Boosts my side of the bid in comparison to your's, plus you get a direct replacement for Hernandez

Page 4 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment