or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 104 comments are related to an article called:

greatest ever national 11's

Page 3 of 5

posted on 26/3/13

jay,

no, he'll still be bitter about owen playing for utd

posted on 26/3/13

England XI

Banks

Neville
Moore
Adams
Cole

Charlton
Scholes
Robson
Edwards
Gascoigne

Greaves

posted on 26/3/13

comment by It's a Mexican Rave!!!! Con Los Terroristas! (U6687)

==================

No, Stanley Matthews?

posted on 26/3/13

ahead of who?

posted on 26/3/13

Where's Heskey?!

posted on 26/3/13

Stanley Matthews ahead of any in MF bar Charlton.

Possibly, England's greatest ever footballer.

posted on 26/3/13

Players I saw play -

Oliver Kahn

Cafu Maldini Kohler R Carlos

Xavi Iniesta

Ronaldinho Zidane Rivaldo

Portly Ronaldo

posted on 26/3/13

Besides, you need width in that set-up and Sir Stanley Matthews provides you with that.

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 26/3/13

You could just as easily swtch Kahn with Buffon, really you should find some space somewhere for either Ronaldo slimline or Messi, probably ahead of Rivaldo.

posted on 26/3/13

D'J,

What about moving Houghton wide right and bringing John Giles in the centre? Giles was just about the best passer of a ball I've ever seen. Your greatest ever player IMO. Although him and Keane in a midfield together would see a fair few tough tackles thrown in.

Shows the ability of your midfield when you can't find a place for Ronnie Whelan, who was a class act. Pretty strong team there.

posted on 26/3/13

Germany

Maier

Vogts
Beckenbauer
Kohler
Schnellinger

Breitner

Mattheus
Overath
Netzer

Muller
Walter

posted on 26/3/13

You could just as easily swtch Kahn with Buffon, really you should find some space somewhere for either Ronaldo slimline or Messi, probably ahead of Rivaldo.

----

Its difficult Jay I chose players who shone at international level.

Ronaldo slim and Messi arent that great internationally for me.

posted on 26/3/13

comment by The Galloping Major (U7010)



posted 49 minutes ago


Scotland

Leighton

Mackay
Miller
Hansen
Nicol

Baxter
Bremner
Souness
Johnstone

Dalglish
Law

--------------------

Archie Gemmil gotta be in there for just THAT goal

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 26/3/13

Messi seems to be just about coming in to it recently, but I see your point

posted on 26/3/13

Ninja, Buffon 06 world cup was better than anything Khan ever did at international level. Not a slight on Khan, whom was magnificent in 02.

posted on 26/3/13

Maier

Lahm
Beckenbauer
Kohler
Brehme

Hassler
Littbarski
Matthaus
Moller

Muller
Rumenigge

posted on 26/3/13

Messi seems to be just about coming in to it recently, but I see your point

----

I hope he does would be good to prove his critics wrong that he can do it on the international level too he deserves it.

posted on 26/3/13

Ninja, Buffon 06 world cup was better than anything Khan ever did at international level. Not a slight on Khan, whom was magnificent in 02.
---

DTKF Kahn was one of personal fav keepers along with Rustu but Buffon has been consistently one of the best if not the best

posted on 26/3/13

comment by Darren The King Fletcher (U10026)
posted 41 seconds ago
Ninja, Buffon 06 world cup was better than anything Khan ever did at international level.

========================

I disagree, IMO.

Both were top keepers but Kahn circa 02 was simply sensational: he, along with a burgeoning Ballack were Germany's only shining lights in a very poor German team.

posted on 26/3/13

oli kahn may have been brilliant in the 02 world cup, but he still cost germany big time in the final, the first goal was entirely his fault, you cant look past such a big error IMO

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 26/3/13

Every time I see Kahn's name I just imagine it being yelled like KKKAAAAHHHNNNNN. That probably makes me slightly weird

posted on 26/3/13

scotland have had some decent players over the years, the same as wales, so why are they so sheite now??

wales had a team that included southall, hughes and rush.

posted on 26/3/13

---------------------Banks---------------
Nev--------Adams------Moore-----Cole
---------Charlton----Robbo-Edwards
---------------Gazza----Scholes------
---------------------Greaves------------

posted on 26/3/13

Fair play. Khan was fantastic. Buffon has surpassed him for club and country, in my opinion.

Buffon has always been a personal favourite of mine, so we probably won't agree. Certainly two of the greatest keepers to play the game.

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 26/3/13

---------------------Banks---------------
Nev--------Adams------Moore-----Cole
---------Charlton----Robbo-Edwards
---------------Gazza----Scholes------
---------------------Greaves------------

Christmas tree formation

Speaking of England management. What we really need is Mike Basset.

Page 3 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment