or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 26 comments are related to an article called:

Adel Tarabt: Yes or NO??

Page 1 of 2

comment by Neo (U9135)

posted on 5/5/13

I wouldn't pay half that.

Taarabt is a selfish, frustratingly inconsistent player and is massively overrated IMO. He only stands out at QPR as the rest of them are absolute cack.

I'd probably take Remy on a cut price deal but that's it.

posted on 5/5/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Philo (U3120)

posted on 5/5/13

i'm not sure. maybe he's more selfish because he's playing with some poor players. maybe rodgers could sit him down and get him to look up every now and then. the guy definitely has the ability, just needs to apply himself better.

posted on 5/5/13

I wouldn't have any QPR players.

posted on 5/5/13

I would maybe take Cesar and Remy as back up but that's about it. Tarabt has a bad attitude problem and tbh i think he has been massively overrated because of 1 good season in the championship.

posted on 5/5/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 5/5/13

Fck no!!! So inconsistent, he goes from pub team player to top 4 quality so often in a game its unbelievable. We do not want him at all...no.no..no.

posted on 5/5/13

NO!!

posted on 5/5/13

NO FRACKING WAY!!!

comment by Reggie (U13390)

posted on 5/5/13

NO.

comment by RedMen7 (U8888)

posted on 5/5/13

Hahaha I was just thinking about him watching the game, he's the sort of player you get Sunday league with his white boots and socks pulled over his knees.

No end product he pants, he will once a season score a great goal then dines out on it all season, he's not a top player, he should stay in the lower leagues and be a big fish in a small pond.

posted on 5/5/13

He has top drawer ability and non league mentality.

No.

comment by Szoboss (U6997)

posted on 5/5/13

Absolutely not.

I think his best chance of a big club would be to head back to France of he can convince the likes of Lyon, Lille, Monaco etc to take a punt on him. He might rebuild his career in a weaker league. Although QPR have probably got him on stupid money so he might just sit tight!

posted on 5/5/13

no and if the manager signed him my faith in him would be destroyed

posted on 5/5/13

no!

posted on 5/5/13

QPR rate taarabt at £15m........






..................

..................OUCH!!

posted on 5/5/13

I've had a think and it's a bigger NO!

posted on 5/5/13

I can see him going to Everton or Newcastle and really looking the part.

posted on 5/5/13

Anyway,adel has bigger fish to fry.
Angling for a PSG or some other oil rich club to make their move,failing that,another album will be in the offing this summer,rolling in the deep part II.





posted on 5/5/13

He does have more goals in the league than Downing.

posted on 5/5/13

Overall taarabt has 5 goals 5 assists
Downing has 5 goals 9 assists

Major imrovement?

comment by Szoboss (U6997)

posted on 5/5/13

I can see him going to Everton or Newcastle and really looking the part.

============

Really? I can't see him getting into the first team at Everton and if Pardew played him ahead of Ben Arfa then he'd need his head examined.

posted on 5/5/13

Overall taarabt has 5 goals 5 assists
Downing has 5 goals 9 assists

Major imrovement?
==============================
1 player plays for Liverpool with Gerrard and Suarez
1 player plays for QPR with Bobby Zomara

Also I did say the league but the above stats are for all appearances which has Downing playing in 42 games and Adel playing 29 games this season

posted on 5/5/13

He's got the talent and then some. Bags of it. But he was dropped on his his head too many times as a baby, toddler, kid and adult though. Something broke.

posted on 5/5/13

Not for me,just a squad filler,got enough of those,we need genuine consistant quality,not another enigma.
Attitude stinks and does'nt match his own hype.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment