or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 170 comments are related to an article called:

How much would you estimate our players at?

Page 3 of 7

posted on 2/6/13

or West Ham. I mean 15m for Carroll

posted on 2/6/13

Or chelsea, 50m for torres

posted on 2/6/13

No it's not relevant because we are talking about what players are worth in the current market. The current British transfer market always over inflates young English talent. Or are you disputing that?

Phil Jones only cost £16m as he was young and English. He wasn't worth it at that point but that was his UK market value.

posted on 2/6/13

Welbeck is probably around £10m-£12m considering his age and the fact he is English.

Doesn't change the fact he needs to up his game massively...

posted on 2/6/13

That's what you were willing to pay not what he's worth

Big difference

comment by Tu Meke (U3732)

posted on 2/6/13

Jenkinson is a young England international ffs

posted on 2/6/13

I would be surprised at under £15M personally...

posted on 2/6/13

I would have Welbeck around 10-15 million and Hernandez at 25-30 million.

comment by Tu Meke (U3732)

posted on 2/6/13

posted on 2/6/13

How is Welbeck rated at 10-15m when Michu was signed for 2m??

posted on 2/6/13

Wayne & Robin so Michu is only worth £2M is he?

posted on 2/6/13

"I would have Welbeck around 10-15 million and Hernandez at 25-30 million."
===

best one yet.

posted on 2/6/13

How is Welbeck rated at 10-15m when Michu was signed for 2m??
-------------
This logic can be applied to pretty much any transfer that takes place.

posted on 2/6/13

Well Swansea signed him for 2m. I would rate him certainly than the 2 goal a season Welbeck

posted on 2/6/13

Well Swansea signed him for 2m.
.............................................

Then what is the point in this topic at all Wayne & Robin?!

If all players are worth exactly what they signed for you could just go on wiki and copy paste whatever fee we paid for the player...

Stop being an idiot!

posted on 2/6/13

How is Welbeck rated at 10-15m when Michu was signed for 2m

--

Michu was a bargain find, he'll be worth atleast 20 million now. The fact is Welbeck is playing for one of the biggest teams in the world and has 4 years on his contract (I think). That will bring his price up, and he's only 22.

posted on 2/6/13

How is Welbeck rated at 10-15m when Michu was signed for 2m??
-------------
This logic can be applied to pretty much any transfer that takes place
-------------------------------------------------------------------
I know mate but Welbeck is nowhere worth 15m even if he s young or not.
Same with Zaha.

posted on 2/6/13

Rafael's curls, this is the first time I've come across you on here. You're making a good first impression. Your future is promising, youngbuck.

posted on 2/6/13

Well Swansea signed him for 2m
--------------
I think everyone knows that was an absolute steal.

It's like me saying Carroll is worth £35m so Welbeck is easily worth £40m

posted on 2/6/13

Rafael's curls, this is the first time I've come across you on here
-----------
Doubt it

posted on 2/6/13

Young buck??
Isn't Kamran just 19 yet??

posted on 2/6/13

I don't think logic is really Wayne & Robin's thing....

posted on 2/6/13

What was your previous display name, sir?

posted on 2/6/13

I am a new member. Long time reader first time poster

posted on 2/6/13

you are a good human being. think you'll go to heaven for making so much sense.

Page 3 of 7

Sign in if you want to comment