For his age, I think Coutinho already possesses more quality than some of the other names you mention

Mata, Cazorla, Kagawa, Coutinho, Silva

Not sure why Kagawas on the list tbh nowhere near as good as the rest

I'd go with
Mata
Coutinho
Cazorla/Kagawa
Silva

Not sure why Kagawas on the list tbh nowhere near as good as the rest

----------



what a cocckk

Silva's so crap it's laughable, i don't see what people see in him. He has a good performance now and again which he should considering he plays for Man City in a team packed full of talent, he rarely turns up for any big game and apart from a good first season where he looked good he has been poor ever since

Not sure why Kagawas on the list tbh nowhere near as good as the rest

---

If you base it on season just finished then neither should Silva.

Kagawa is a very talented player but for various reasons didn't quite show it this season (same with Silva)

Mata
Hazard
Silva
Nani
Kagawa
Coutinho
Cazorla

Going by what we saw from them last season.

Mata, Cazorla, Kagawa, Silva, Coutinho

................

In even more context only Mata looked a 100% class act. All the others flattered to deceive on many an occasion.

some idiots (city boy) seem to think players can just step into the premier league and succeed.

Mata and silva took a full season before they showed their full abilities.

As for Coutinho, the boy is decent, but for me i wonder how much of it is him standing out in an average liverpool team ( no offence meant).

City boy
-----------------------------
Bundesliga player of the year for a Dortmund team that won the league a head of an amazing Bayern team the season before. Most Utd fans want him starting ahead of Rooney as well which says something

Silva is extremely overrated IMO.

On this season alone

Mata, Cazorla, Coutinho, Kagawa then Silva

Based on actual talent and ability

Mata, Kagawa, Silva, Cazorla then Coutinho

Mata, Kagawa, Cazorla, Silva

Haven't seen enough of Coutinho.

comment by The Voice in Platini's head - LAKochienly (U16421) posted 1 minute ago
City boy
-----------------------------
Bundesliga player of the year for a Dortmund team that won the league a head of an amazing Bayern team the season before. Most Utd fans want him starting ahead of Rooney as well which says something

-----------
I thought he was Bundesliga player of the season too but turns out he wasn't

So far, Kagawa has done zip at United to suggest he could fill Wayne Rooney's boots. Time will tell though because we clearly have not seen the best of Shinji just yet

There is bound to be some club bias in what people put on their list. Personally, I see them as players who all offer something slightly different to each other, so I'm not sure a comparison works anyway.

If I was to judge on natural talent, then Kagawa and silva but not based on form this season.

As much as I love Kagawa, can people stop referring to him as Bundesliga player of the year? He wasn't, that was one poll on one website for English speakers.

They are all average compared to all the greats of yesteryear.

Mata, Nani, Hazard, Kagawa, Cazorla, Silva



All complete flops in the CL this season. Very overrated.

When on their game,

Mata, Silva, Cazorla.

Kagawa and Coutinho have not had enough game time for me yet.

Silva overated?

When in full flow there is no nicer footballer to watch.

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

My mistake. Though he clearly was an important part of that Dortmund team

My dad > Your dad
My car > Your car
My football club > Your football club
My mrs > Your gay partner

Silva on form is amazing, he is a great player but he's so inconsistent sometimes. I don't know if Mancini and him did not get on last season, but he's top class.

manutd1982 (U6633)



posted 2 minutes ago


On this season alone

Mata, Cazorla, Coutinho, Kagawa then Silva

Based on actual talent and ability

Mata, Kagawa, Silva, Cazorla then Coutinho
---------------------------------------------------------------
what??!!! so did they not play this season based on actual talent and ability??

your first list is based on the way they have played in the prem the 2nd list is based on what...???

how have you managed to quantify 'actual talent and ability' if not on the way they play football...??

some people

Comment deleted by Site Moderator