or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 141 comments are related to an article called:

Most overrated players in the league?

Page 1 of 6

posted on 8/6/13

Rafael

posted on 8/6/13

http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3g028QmXd1ql8gop.jpg

posted on 8/6/13

Bale

posted on 8/6/13

Cleverly, welbeck, Theo, young,

posted on 8/6/13

Walcott

posted on 8/6/13

david luiz!

posted on 8/6/13

Comment deleted by Article Creator

posted on 8/6/13

Comment deleted by Article Creator

posted on 8/6/13

People constantly say Luiz can't defend how on earth do you come to the conclusion he's overrated?

posted on 8/6/13

Spurs minus Bale

posted on 8/6/13

Ramsey, serious chat here. no WUMMING please. On that note - Aaron Ramsey, the next xavi.

posted on 8/6/13

Why did you delete my factual comment?

posted on 8/6/13

For Koscielny to be over rated he would have to be rated by people in the first place

posted on 8/6/13

Okay I'll give this thread 2 minutes

posted on 8/6/13

1 from each team:

Utd: Carrick, I think he is class but people make out like he is Pirlo
City: Kompany, never really understood the hype he is good but I genuinely think Kaboul is better
Chelsea: Hazard, not a bad player but not very threatening in the final third
Arsenal: Podolski, good on the ball but the worst player I have seen in the top 10 off it
Spurs: Vertonghen, some of the worst defensive positioning I have seen in a while, Vermaelen-esque
Everton: Fellaini, talented but I think Baines, Jags, Distin, Coleman, Mirallas, Pineaar are more valuable for Everton
Liverpool: Johnson, he is bland, plain and average
West Brom: Lukaku, top for a 19 year old, but if he performs like he did this season at 26 I would be more worried, he isnt all that
Swansea: Angel Rangel, I just dont rate this guy one bit
West Ham: Nolan, so average it winds me up

CBA with bottom half teams

posted on 8/6/13

I know a lot of chelsea fans who would prefer him at center half. At center half, overrated. In central midfield, a rough gem.

posted on 8/6/13

But barely anyone rates him so how is he overrated

do people understand what overrated means?

posted on 8/6/13

Kompany, never really understood the hype he is good but I genuinely think Kaboul is better
---------------------------------

posted on 8/6/13

Depends Fat Ron, I would say Chelsea fans on this website overrate Luiz but everyone else probably underrates him

posted on 8/6/13

That's fair

posted on 8/6/13

Rooney, ramsey, walcott, welbeck, cleverly, zaha... none of those would be that higher rated if they weren't British. Rooney was very talented but has lost it.

posted on 8/6/13

If they prefer him as their first choice center half, they rate him better there than neutral parties, hence i consider overrated in that position. My opinion, doesnt have to be yours.

posted on 8/6/13

Imo Silva, Santi, RVP and Aguero are the most overrated.

Most underrated have to be Welbeck and Cleverly. World class players already. On an off day best players in the league, on an on day best in the world.

posted on 8/6/13

I don't get this thing about Rooney being no good anymore. Played out of position and got 12 goals and 13 assists in 25 games I think. Seems a bit harsh to me but I do not watch Utd that much.

posted on 8/6/13

Dunno if its out of position considering how he has changed as a player

Page 1 of 6

Sign in if you want to comment