or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 51 comments are related to an article called:

Transfer Window Shuts: Voting Open

Page 2 of 3

comment by T-BAD (U11806)

posted on 3/9/13

- Who was the best player signed in the window : In terms of ability. Barry
__________

What?

posted on 3/9/13

- Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement - its hard to look past spurs, but i think Man City have added a new dimension to their squad

- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement
Newcatle really havent addressed any of their problems

- Who was the best player signed in the window
Ozil

- Who was the best value signing of the window
hes likely to be on a kings ransom, but i think etoo will do well for chelsea

- Best darkhorse signing of the window
a bit biased, but i can see borini doing well at sunderland, other than him, i can see bent and redmond doing well at their new clubs

- Post window: Which manager is under most pressure to deliver ? AVB without a doubt

posted on 3/9/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 3/9/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 3/9/13

- Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement -

Most people will say spurs but i don't think the players they've bought are that great as they are making out apart from soldado and then Eriksen was a bargain he will be so good in the future, always thought Ajax would sell him for up to £40m, i think Lamela will be very hit and miss and don't think capoue will do very well

- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement

Newcastle

- Who was the best player signed in the window

Ozil instantly, eriksen definitely for the future

- Who was the best value signing of the window

Eto'o

- Best darkhorse signing of the window

Lukaku

- Post window: Which manager is under most pressure to deliver ?

Di Canio to be sacked first

comment by Radical (U8691)

posted on 3/9/13

Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement
Manchester United

- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement
Chelsea

- Who was the best player signed in the window
Jonjo Shelvey

- Who was the best value signing of the window
Dave Kitson

- Best darkhorse signing of the window
Kaka

- Post window: Which manager is under most pressure to deliver ?

Kevin Blackwell

posted on 3/9/13

- Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement;
Liverpool/Chelsea/Everton/Villa

- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement;
Newcastle.

- Who was the best player signed in the window;
Ozil.

- Who was the best value signing of the window;
Stekelenberg/Toure/Eto'o/Flamini

- Best darkhorse signing of the window;
Bony/Bent

- Post window: Which manager is under most pressure to deliver ?;
Mourinho/AVB/Moyes

posted on 3/9/13

- Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement- Spurs

- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement- Newcastle

- Who was the best player signed in the window- Ozil

- Who was the best value signing of the window- Eto

- Best darkhorse signing of the window- Schrulle

- Post window: Which manager is under most pressure to deliver- AVB

posted on 3/9/13

Stephen Ireland to Stoke is a good contender in the Dark Horse category.

posted on 3/9/13


Right Gentlemen

I've just done a quick count and I can tell you so far that the top 3 in each category are:

Which team had Best window:

Spurs = 8 votes
City = 7 votes
Liverpool = 3 votes

Which team had worst window:

Newcastle = 13 votes
United = 6 votes
efc/arsenal = 1 vote

Best player

Ozil = 20 votes

Best value

Eriksen = 5 votes
Eto'o = 5 votes
Toure = 3 votes

darkhorse

Sessegnon = 4 votes
Lukaku = 3 votes
Leroy Fer = 2 votes

Under Pressure

AVB = 9 votes
Moyes = 7 votes
Wenger = 5 votes

posted on 3/9/13

Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement - Man City

- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement- Due to the fact that United already have a very good team in place I am going to have to go with Newcastle.

- In terms of pure quality it has to be Ozil, still tink Arsenal could have done with a couple more excellent players though

- Best value- Kolo Toure, Lakaku or Eto

- Best darkhorse signing of the window, Gareth Barry and Bent

- Post window: Whiich managed is under the most pressure to deliver? Moyes and Di Canio. Moyes because he has to deliver a high level of success despite transfer failures and Di Canio, well due to the sheer volume of signings he has brought in and due to his repuataion as well. If things get tough the press will be all over him unfortunatly.

posted on 3/9/13

Ooooh good post Metro...........


- Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement... Probably Chelsea with Eto, Atsu and Willian

- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement...I'm going for Spurs. They've brought in a handful of good players but by losing a world class player in Bale they've gone backwards.

- Who was the best player signed in the window...Ozil is excellent, he's probably the one, although overpriced.

- Who was the best value signing of the window...Eto on a free isn't bad but Kolo on a free has been a revelation at the heart of Liverpool's defence so he's the one.

- Best darkhorse signing of the window...If Borini is given plenty of playing time at Sunderland he'll flourish I think.

- Post window: Which manager is under most pressure to deliver ? Plenty of candidates here...Moyes is in a job that is frankly too big for him, Maureen has been hailed as the second coming, wenger has already had fans calling for his head after 90 minutes of the season starting, Pellegrini has bosses who don't understand football and think their team should win the treble every year and Pardew's boss is just an idiot.

Having stepped into ol' whisky nose' slippers I think i'll go for smeagol, whoops sorry moyes that is.





posted on 3/9/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 3/9/13


You mean that was the same Eto'o...........

posted on 3/9/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 3/9/13

How many Eto'o's are there?

posted on 3/9/13


Eone

Eto'o

Ethree

posted on 3/9/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 3/9/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 3/9/13

My dark horse signing goes to Borini, good luck sir, have a great season.

posted on 3/9/13

- Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement

You could say City or Spurs, but they have lost Barry, Tevez and Bale, Dempsey, Parker, while their additions are at least on par with their losses if not better their actual 'net' improvement isn't great.

I would say Southampton have improved a lot in areas across their squad and haven't lost any important players. We have also improved squad quality a lot IMO.
- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement?

Newcastle, WBA

- Who was the best player signed in the window

Ozil

- Who was the best value signing of the window

Not Anelka. Probably Eto'o

- Best darkhorse signing of the window

McCarthy

- Post window: Which manager is under most pressure to deliver ?

Moyes and Mourinho

Also Fellaini will be the flop. Heard it here first.

comment by Red Led (U1731)

posted on 3/9/13

- Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement ~ Spurs / Liverpool

- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement ~ Newcastle

- Who was the best player signed in the window ~ Ozil

- Who was the best value signing of the window ~ Toure / Eto

- Best darkhorse signing of the window ~ Borini. I have a sneaky feeling he could be a revelation, given playing time.

- Post window: Which manager is under most pressure to deliver ~ Has to be either AVB having spent so much, or Moyes purely because of the expectation.

posted on 3/9/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 3/9/13

- Which Team had the best window in terms of squad quality improvement
Spurs

- Which team had the worst window in terms of squad quality improvement
Newcastle

- Who was the best player signed in the window
Ozil

- Who was the best value signing of the window
Lukaku/Mignolet

- Best darkhorse signing of the window
Capoue, when settled, could be a beast

- Post window: Which manager is under most pressure to deliver ?
Unfortunately, AVB / Moyes/Wenger

posted on 3/9/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Page 2 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment