Thudd. That's the thing, on his day he's great. On other days he looks like he's the worst CB in the PL. Other very good CB's don't give that impression.

Both are different types of players RGK, I'm ,like GNev, I hate to compare when two types of players are different in style

Respected

You seem a bit wound up.

Verthoghen makes far more mistakes than Koscielny does. There is a reason why you lot conceded 46 goals last season in the league. It is because Verthoghen isn't that good.

Koscielny's mistakes are more embarrassing. Schoolboy errors.

He's not been sent off yet, he has a solid disciplinary record, both players are prone to mistakes, so I'd say both are on the same level

No Verthoghen's mistakes is embarrassing. Which is why you conceded 46 goals.

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

RKG and Kam to an extent are Arsenal fans who have so much hatred for Spurs they tend not to give players credit, I'd happily praise another player but also point out my owns failings

Vertonghen got into last season's PL Team of the Year. I didn't see Koscielny on there.

Raptor you're a idiot. Even our friend Chronic thinks Verthoghen is a liability. Verthoghen is a good ball playing defender but not near the best defenders in the league at all. All your spurs fans claim your players is better than all our players but why dont you finish above us then if that is the case.

He's on level par with Kos in my opinion, they both have good strengths and attributes, Kos tends to make good last second tackles, where Vertonghen reads the game well,

Considering Spurs finished 1 point behind Arsenal it's fair to say they both had a good season

Walker got young player of the year when he is garbage. Giggs won player of the year in 2009 when he wasn't even close to being the best at his club. Vermaelen got into team of the year once and he is a liability. You're a clown spurtle. Those awards mean nothing.

Its as if RGK is screaming in Spurtle's face.

Not close to Koscielny at all. Nowhere near.

That's your opionion RGK

We will ask a netural level headed fan

Mr C, opinions on Kos and Vertonghen?

Respected

Your va gina is showing.

Vertonghen is as good if not better defensively, and offers more going forward. He's a better pick.

RGK putting Spurtle on to the sword..

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

I'd put Anthony Gardner above Kos

Thudd , I dont watch much of yours and Arsenals games. Only twice a season when you play us and I got a sht memory to boot so its difficult for me to pick between them.

Spurtle you're a v agina discharge and a t!t. Deluded idiot that knows fack all about football. Verthoghen is barely any better than Vermaelen let alone close to Koscielny's level.

Verthoghen is barely any better than Vermaelen

OH MY DAYZ!!!!

RGK sign out mate, you've finally lost it